Gleb L. Krivolapov, Lomonosov Moscow State University, Moscow, Russia, Russian State University for the Humanities, Moscow, Russia, E-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Ekaterina V. Snedkova, Lomonosov Moscow State University, Moscow, Russia, E-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Albrecht, M.v. 2002: Istoriya rimskoy literatury [A History of Roman Literature]. Vol. I. Moscow.

Альбрехт, М. фон. 2002: История римской литературы. Т. I. М.

Angel, N. 2007: Clementia Caesaris: the creation and dissemination of a reputation. PhD. Sydney.

Baehrens, E. (ed.) 1886: Fragmenta poetarum Romanorum. Leipzig.

Baraz, E. 2020: Bitter Medicine of History: Seneca the Elder on the Genre of Declamation. In: M.T. Dinter, Ch. Guérin, M. Martinho (eds.), Reading Roman Declamation. Seneca the Elder. Oxford, 15–36.

Bonnet, M. 1889: Sénèque Suasoria 6 et Controversiae 2 et 3. Revue de philologie, de littérature et d’histoire anciennes 13, 140–141.

Borukhovich V.G. 1976: V mire antichnykh svitkov [In the World of Ancient Scrolls]. Saratov.

Борухович, В.Г. 1976: В мире античных свитков. Саратов.

Brakman, C. 1910: Annaeana Nova Velleana Ad Scriptores Hist. Aug. Ad Panegyricos Latinos. Leiden.

Bornecque, H. 1902: Sénèque le Rhéteur. Controverses et Suasoires. 2 vols. Paris.

Bursian, K. (ed.) 1857: Annaei Senecae Oratorum et rhetorum sententiae divisiones colores. Leipzig.

Castiglioni, L. 1927: In Senecam rhetorem, Pomponium Melam, Cornelium Nepotem, animadversiones criticae. In: A. Gemelli et al. (eds.), Raccolta di scritti in onore di Felice Ramorino. Milan, 101–129.

Cornell, T.J. (ed.) 2013: The Fragments of the Roman Historians. 3 vols. Oxford.

Drummond, A. 2013: C. Asinius Pollio. In: T.J. Cornell (ed.), The Fragments of the Roman Historians. Vol. I. Introduction. Oxford, 430–445.

Edward, W.A. (ed.) 1928: The suasoriae of Seneca the Elder. Cambridge.

Feddern, S. (ed.) 2013: Die Suasorien des älteren Seneca: Einleitung, Text und Kommentar. Berlin–Boston, 2013.

Frank, T. 1913: Marginalia. American Journal of Philology 34/3, 322–328.

Håkanson, L. (ed.) 1989: L. Annaeus Seneca Maior. Oratorum et rhetorum sententiae divisiones colores. Leipzig.

Hollis, A.S. (ed./tr.) 2007: Fragments of Roman poetry, c.60 BC–AD 20. Oxford.

Kenty, J. 2017: Messalla Corvinus: Augustan Orator, Ciceronian Statesman. Rhetorica 35/4, 445–474.

Kiessling, A. (ed.) 1872: Annaei Senecae Oratorum et rhetorum sententiae divisiones colores. Leipzig.

Levick, B. 2013a: A. Cremutius Cordus. In: T.J. Cornell (ed.), The Fragments of the Roman Historians. Vol. I. Introduction. Oxford, 592–593.

Levick, B. 2013b: Aufidius Bassus. In: T.J. Cornell (ed.), The Fragments of the Roman Historians. Vol. I. Introduction. Oxford, 603–605.

Levick, B. 2013c: Bruttedius Niger. In: T.J. Cornell (ed.), The Fragments of the Roman Historians. Vol. I. Introduction. Oxford, 594.

Lucarini, C.M. 2008: Vindiciae Annaeanae. In: P. Arduini et al. (eds.), Studi offerti ad Alessandro Perutelli. Vol. II. Rome, 137–145.

Müller, H.J. (ed.) 1887: L. Annaei Senecae Oratorum et rhetorum sententiae divisiones colores. Wien.

Pieper, Ch. 2019: How not to commemorate Cicero: Asinius Pollio in Seneca’s sixth suasoria. Histos 13, 158–174.

Rebling, O. 1868: Observationes criticae in L. Annaeum Senecam patrem. Göttingen.

Snedkova, E.V. 2023: Pochemu Seneka schitayetsya rodonachal'nikom pervykh publichnykh retsitatsiy v Rime? [Why did Seneca the elder consider Gaius Asinius Pollio to be a founder of the first public recitations in Rome?]. Vestnik Yaroslavskogo gocudarstvennogo universiteta im. P. G. Demidova. Seriya Humanitarnye nauki [Journal of P. G. Demidov Yaroslavl State University. Series Humanities] 17/4, 544–553.

Снедкова, Е.В. 2023: Почему Сенека считается родоначальником первых публичных рецитаций в Риме? Вестник Ярославского государственного университета им. П.Г. Демидова. Серия Гуманитарные науки 17/4, 544–553.

van der Vliet, J. 1895: Sur les Suasoriae VI et VII de Sénèque. Revue de philologie, de littérature et d’histoire anciennes 19, 38–42.

Walter, F. 1918: Zu Tacitus und Seneca Rhetor. Berliner Philologische Wochenschrift 38, 237– 240.

Watt, W.S. 1984: Notes on Seneca ’Rhetor’. Harvard Studies in Classical Philology 88, 103–112.

Winterbottom, M. 1974a: Problems in the elder Seneca. Bulletin of the Institute of Classical Studies 21, 20–42.

Winterbottom, M. (ed./tr.) 1974b: The Elder Seneca. Declamations. 2 vols. Cambridge.

Zanon dal Bo, A. (tr./ann.) 1988: Seneca il Vecchio, Oratori e Retori. Controversie, Libro X – Suasorie e frammenti. Bologna.

download PDF

Abstract

The worship of the sacred animals became an important aspect of Egyptian culture in the Late Period and especially during the Ptolemaic rule. For the first time the idea of care about the sacred animals was widely used for purposes of propaganda. This article examines these propaganda messages to understand in which ways the kings showed their care about the sacred animals. It seems that the kings often visited the sacred animals, enthroned the new ones and paid for their burials and temples. That begs the question why Ptolemies used this aspect of propaganda so frequently. Reasons for it are twofold. On the one hand, in the Late Egypt and especially in the time of Persian rule over it, it became quite popular to spread the stories of sacrileges done by Persian rulers. It often involved mutilation of the sacred animals, their killing and eating. Ptolemies who did not commit such atrocities but just the other way round cared about the animals and treated them well could be favorably compared with foreign rulers of old and thus could be viewed as legitimate rulers of Egypt. On the other hand, this aspect of propaganda could be well understood by Ptolemies’ Greek subjects and by the members of the dynasty themselves. It is well known that Herodotus in his works described in detail the importance of the sacred animals for Egypt.

Keywords

Ancient Egypt, Hellenism, Ptolemies, sacred animals, Apis, Egyptian clergy.

Mikhail S. Apenko

Lomonosov Moscow State University, Moscow, Russia;

Institute of World History of the Russian Academy of Science, Moscow, Russia

E-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Altmann, V. 2010: Die Kultfrevel des Seth: Die Gefährdung der göttlichen Ordnung in zwei Vernichtungsritualen der ägyptischen Spätzeit (Urk. VI) (Studien zur spätägyptischen Religion, 1). Wiesbaden.

Apenko, M.S. 2023: Mesto Manefona Sevennitskogo v egipetskoy zhrecheskoy korporatsii [Manetho of Sebennytos and His Role in the Egyptian Priesthood]. Problemy istorii, filologii, kul’tury [Journal of Historical, Philological and Cultural Studies] 1, 108–123

Arnold, D. 1999: Temples of the last Pharaohs. New York–Oxford.

Barta, W. 1980: Thronbesteigung und Kronungsfeier als unterschiedliche Zeugnisse königlicher Herrschaftsübernahme. Studien zur altägyptischen Kultur 8, 33–53.

Berlev, O.D. 1979: «Zolotoe imya» egipetskogo tsarya [“The Golden Name” of Egyptian King]. In: I.S. Katsnelson (ed.), Zh.F. Shampol’on i deshifrovka egipetskikh ieroglifov [J.-Fr. Champollion and the Decipherment of the Egyptian Hieroglyphs]. Moscow, 41–59.

Blöbaum, A.I. 2006: “Denn ich bin ein König, der Maat liebt”: Herrscherlegitimation im spätzeitlichen Ägypten. Aachen.

Brugsch, H. 1894: Die Pithomstele. Zeitschrift für ägyptische Sprache and Altertumskunde 32, 74–87.

Burstein, S.M. 1991: Pharaoh Alexander: A Scholarly Myth. Ancient Society 22, 139–145.

Dandamaev, M.A., Lukonin, V.G. 1980: Kul’tura i ekonomika drevnego Irana [Culture and Economy of Ancient Iran]. Moscow.

De Meulenaere, H., MacKay, P. 1976: Mendes II. Wärmster.

Demidchik, A.E. 2005: Besymyannaya piramida. Gosudarstvennaya doktrina drevneeyegipetskoy monarkhii [A Nameless Pyramid: The State Doctrine of the Ancient Egyptian Heracleopolitan Monarchy]. Saint Petersburg.

Devauchelle, D. 1994: Les steles du Sérapéum de Memphis conservées au Musée du Louvre. Acta Demotica: Acts of the Fifth International Conference for Demotists (Pisa, 4th–8th September 1993). Pise, 95–114.

Dillery, J. 2004: Cambyses and the Egyptian Chaosbeschreibung Tradition. Classical Quarterly 55, 387–406.

El-Masry, Y., Altenmuller, H., Thissen, H.J. 2012: Das Synodaldekret von Alexandria aus dem Jahre 243 v. Chr. Hamburg.

Gladić, D.A. 2015: Das Dekret von Memphis. Kommentar und Auswertung. Ph.D. Diss. Trier. [https://ubt.opus.hbz-nrw.de/frontdoor/index/index/year/2018/docId/829]

Gorre, G., Veisse, A. 2020: Birth and disappearance of the priestly synods in the time of the Ptolemies. In: G. Gorre, St. Wackenier (eds.), Quand la fortune du royaume ne dépend pas de la vertu du prince: Un renforcement de la monarchie lagide de Ptolémée VI à Ptolémée X (169–88 av. J.–C.). Leuven, 113–140.

Gozzoli, R. 2006: The Writing of History in Ancient Egypt during the First Millennium B.C. (ca. 1070–180). Trends and Perspectives (Golden House Publications, Egyptology, 5). London.

Grayson, A. K. 1975: Assyrian and Babylonian Chronicles. Locust Valley–New York.

Hölbl, G. A 2001: History of the Ptolemaic Empire. London–New York.

Huß, W. 1978: Eine Revolte der Ägypter in der Zeit der 3. Syrischen Krieg. Aegyptus 58, 151– 156.

Huß, W. 1991: Die in ptolemaiischen Zeit verfaßten Synodal-Dekreten der ägyptischen Priester. ZPE 88, 189–208.

Huß, W. 1998: Ptolemaios der Sohn. ZPE 121, 229–250.

Kessler, D. 1989: Die heiligen Tiere und der König. Wiesbaden.

Kessler, D. 2003: Tierische Missverständnisse: Grundsätzliches zu Fragen des Tierkultes. In: M. Fitzenreiter (Hrsg.), Tierkulte im pharaonischen Ägypten und im Kulturvergleich. Berlin.

Ladynin, I.A. 2017: “Snova pravit Egipet!” Nachalo ellinisticheskogo vremeni v kontseptsiyakh i konstruktakh pozdneegipetskikh istoriografii i propagandy [“Egypt Rules Again!” The Start of the Hellenistic Period in the Concepts and Constructs of Late Egyptian Historiography and Propaganda]. Saint Petersburg.

Ladynin, I.A. 2007: 3–ya Siriyskaya voyna i zakhvat Ptolemeem III v Azii kul’tovykh predmetov v svedeniyakh knigi Daniila i Porfiriya Tirskogo [The Third Syrian War and the capture of sacred objects in Asia by Ptolemy III as represented in the Book of Daniel and by Porphyry of Tyros]. Antiquitas aeterna 2, 273–287.

Ladynin, I.A. 2009: “Sokoly-Nektaneby”. Skulpturnye izobrazheniya Nektaneba II pered bogom Khorom i ikh kontseptsiya [“Nectanebos-the-Falcons”: sculpture images of Nectanebo II before the god Horus and their concept]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 4, 3–26.

Ladynin, I.A. 2013: Svedeniya Psevdo-Aristotelevoy «Ekonomiki» o Kleomene iz Navkratisa i toposy drevneegipetskoy propagandy [Cleomenes of Naucratis in Pseudo-Aristoteles’ Oeconomica and the Topoi of Ancient Egyptian Propaganda]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 2, 18–40.

Ladynin, I.A. 2014: Ot vmestilishch bogov k magicheskim pomoshchnikam: retseptsiya peredneaziatskogo predstavleniya o kul’tovykh izobrazheniyakh v pozdnem i greko-rimskom Egipte [From the Receptacles of Gods to the Magical Aides: The Reception of the Near Eastern Attitude towards Cult Images in Late and Greco-Roman Egypt]. Uchenye zapiski Kazanskogo universiteta. Seriya Gumanitarnye nauki [Proceedings of the Kazan University. Humanities Series] 156 (3), 158–168.

Ladynin, I.A. 2016: Dinasticheskiy kul’t i eponimnoe zhrechestvo Ptolemeev [The dynastic cult and the eponimous priesthood of the Ptolemies]. In: S.Yu. Saprykin, I.A. Ladynin (eds.), “Bogi sredi ludey”: kul’t praviteley v ellinisticheskom, postellinisticheskom i rimskom mire [“Gods among Men”: The Rulers’ Cult in the Hellenistic, Post-Hellenistic and Roman World]. Moscow, 265–312.

Ladynin, I.A. 2018: Zhizn’ i smert’ odnogo Apisa: ot vtorogo persidskogo vladychestva do satrapii Ptolemeya [Live and Death of an Apis Bull: From the Second Persian Domination to Ptolemy’s Satrapy]. In: S.Yu. Saprykin (ed.), Drevniy Vostok i antichnyy mir [Ancient Orient and the Classical World] 9. Moscow, 35–55.

Ladynin, I.A. 2019: Antichnaya traditsiya o koshchunstvakh Artakserksa III protiv svyashchennykh zhivotnykh i vopros o ee datirovke [The classical tradition about the sacrilege of Artaxerxes III against the ancient Egyptians sacred animals: the problem of dating]. In: I.A. Ladynin (ed.), Vostok, Evropa, Amerika v drevnosti. Vyp. 4. Sbornik nauchnykh trudov Sergeevskikh chteniy na kafedre istorii drevnego mira istoricheskogo fakul’teta MGU imeni M.V. Lomonosova. [Orient, Europe, America in Antiquity. Iss. 4. Proceedings of the XXI Sergeyev Readings, Department of Ancient History, Faculty of History, Lomonosov Moscow State University]. Moscow, Saint-Petersburg, 5–18.

Ladynin, I.A. 2022: Ptolemey, syn Laga, i zhretsy Buto. “Stela satrapa” (Egipetskiy muzey, Kair, 22182): Ieroglificheskiy tekst, perevod i kommentariy [Ptolemy, Son of Lagus, and the Priests of Buto. The Satrap Stela (Egyptian Museum, Cairo, 22182): Hieroglyphic Text, Translation and Commentary]. Moscow–Saint Petersburg.

Ladynin, I.A. 2023: Maski svyashchennyh sokolov s izobrazheniem tsarya iz egipetskogo sobraniya GMII im. A.S. Pushkina [The Masks of Sacred Falcons with the Image of a King in the Egyptian Collection of the A.S. Pushkin Museum of Fine Arts]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 1, 164–184.

Luckenbill, D.D. 1927: Ancient Records of Assyria and Babylonia. Vol. II. Chicago.

Manning, J.G. 2019: The Ptolemaic Governmental Branches and the Role of Temples and Elite Groups. In: K. Vandorpe (ed.), A Companion to Greco-Roman and Late Antique Egypt. Hoboken, 103–118.

McGing, B.C. 1997: Revolt Egyptian Style. Internal Opposition to Ptolemaic Rule. Archiv für Papyrusforschung und verwandte Gebiete 43, 274–314.

Murray, O. 1970: Hecataeus of Abdera and the Pharaonic Kingship. Journal of Egyptian Archaeology 56, 141–171.

Murray, O. 1972: Herodotus and Hellenistic Culture. Classical Quarterly 22, 200–213.

Pfeiffer, St. 2004: Das Dekret von Kanopos (238 v. Chr.). Kommentar und historische Auswertung (APF, Beiheft 18). München; Leipzig.

Priesley, J. 2014: Herodotus and Hellenistic Culture: Literary Studies in the Reception of the Histories. Oxford.

Quack, J.F. 2008: Innovations in ancient Garb? Hieroglyphic texts from the time of Ptolemy Philadelphus. In: P. McKechnie, Ph. Guillaume (eds), Ptolemy II Philadelphus and his World. Boston–Leiden.

Recklinghausen, D. von 2018: Die Philensis-dekrete: Untersuchungen Uber Zwei Synodaldekrete Aus Der Zeit Ptolemaios’ V. Und Ihre Geschichtliche Und Religiose Bedeutung (Ӓgyptologische Abhandlungen, 73). Wiesbaden.

Redford, D.B. 2010: City of Ram-God. The Story of Ancient Mendes. Princeton.

Roeder, G. 1959: Die Agyptische Gotterwelt. Zurich.

Rössler-Köhler, U. 1991: Individuelle Haltungen zum ägyptischen Königtum der Spätzeit: Private Quellenund ihre Königswertung im Spannungsfeld zwischen Erwartung und Erfahrung. (Göttinger Orientforschungen. IV. Reihe: Ägypten, 21). Wiesbaden.

Schäfer, D. 2011: Makedonische Pharaonen und hieroglyphische Stelen: Historische Untersuchungen zur Satrapenstele und verwandten Denkmälern. Leuven.

Schwartz, J. 1949: Les conquêrants perses et la littérature égyptienne. Bulletin de lʼInstitut français dʼarchéologie orientale 48, 65–80.

Spiegelberg, W. 1904: Varia. Recueil de travaux relatifs à la philologie et à l‘archéologie égyptiennes et assyriennes: pour servir de bullletin à la Mission Française du Caire 26, 41–52.

Stern, M., Murray, O. 1973: Hecataeus of Abdera and Theophrastus on Jews and Egyptians. Journal of Egyptian Archaeology 59, 159–168.

Thiers, Chr. 2007: Ptolémée Philadelphe et les prêtres d’Atoum de Tjékou. Nouvelle edition commentée de la “stele de Pithom” (CG 22183). Montpellier.

Thompson, D. 1988. Memphis under the Ptolemies. Princeton.

Velde, H. te 1967: Seth, God of Confusion: A Study of His Role in Egyptian Mythology and Religion (Probleme der Ägyptologie, 6). Leiden.

Winnicki, J.K. 1994: Carrying Off and Bringing Home the Statues of the Gods: On the Aspect of the Religious Policy of the Ptolemies Towards the Egyptians. Journal of Juristic Papyrology 24, 149–190.

download PDF

Abstract

The Hittite-Luwian rituals of the Puriyanni and Kuwattalla traditions (CTH 758–763) contain substitution and scapegoat rites among the rich set of their ritual practices. The substitution rites represent a subset of purification rites and may involve animals or inanimate substitutes. Their terminology displays parallels with that of the substitution rites embedded in Hittite compositions, such as royal substitution rituals (CTH 419–421) or Prayer for Princess Gaššuliyawiya (CTH 380), but there are also important differences. While the scapegoat rites show affinities with the substitution rites, these two categories can be defined separately. The systematic research into both groups of rites was conducive to arriving at several new textual interpretations of Hittite-Luwian rituals. Thus, the damaged passage from the Kuwattalla tradition mentioning “the supreme substitutes” finds a parallel in the texts of the Hittite royal substitution ritual (CTH 421), where different kinds of substitutes are sent to the gods of the Netherworld and to the gods living in the skies respectively. Feeding the nakkiu-spirits during the ritual echoes the passage from the Luwian conjuration belonging to the Tauriša tradition. The interpretation of the adjective šaknuwant(i)-, describing the sacrificial animal presented to the Storm-God, should have a positive connotation, according to its parallels with the description of the substitution ritual in the Prayer for Princess Gaššuliyawiya.

Keywords

Anatolian religion, Hittite-Luwian rituals, Puriyanni tradition, Kuwattalla tradition, substitution rites, substitute, scapegoat.

Valeriy A. Ivanov

Lomonosov Moscow State University, Moscow, Russia

E-mail: v.v.a.ivanoff @yandex.ru

Ambos, C. 2012: Purifying the King by Means of Prisoners, Fish, a Goose, and a Duck. Some Remarks on the Mesopotamian Notions of Purity. In: P. Rösch and U. Simon (eds.), How Purity Is Made. Wiesbaden, 89–103.

Beckman, G. 1999: Hittite Diplomatic Texts. Atlanta.

Bottéro, J. 1992: Mesopotamia. Writing, Reasoning, and the God. Chicago–London.

Collins, B.J. 2022: Orion in Hittite? In: S. De Martino et al. (eds.), Orizzonti d’oriente tra Mediterraneo e Asia Centrale. Studi in ricordo di Sebastiano Tusa (Eothen 25). Rome, 31–44.

Frazer, J.G. 1925: The Golden Bough. A Study in Magic and Religion. Abridged version. New York.

Furlani, G. 1932: Il sacrificio nella religione dei semiti di Babilonia e Assiria. Rome.

Geller, M.J. 2016: Healing Magic and Evil Demons. Canonical Udug-hul Incantations. With the Assistance of Luděk Vacín (Die babylonisch-assyrische Medizin in Texten und Untersuchungen 8). Boston–Berlin.

Goedegebuure, P.M. 2002: KBo 17.17+: Remarks on an Old Hittite Royal Substitution Ritual. Journal of Ancient Near Eastern Religions 2, 61–73.

Gurney, O.R. 1977: Some aspects of Hittite religion. Schweich Lectures of the British Academy 1976. Oxford.

Güterbock, H.G., Hoffner, H.A. 1980: The Hittite dictionary of the Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago. Vol. L–N. Fasc. 1: la- to ma-, (CHD 3/1). Chicago.

Güterbock, H.G. 1951: The Song of Ullikummi. Revised Text of the Hittite Version of a Hurrian Myth. JCS 5, 135–161.

Güterbock, H.G. 1952: The Song of Ullikummi. Revised Text of the Hittite Version of a Hurrian Myth (Continued). JCS 6, 8–42.

Güterbock, H.G. 1983: A Hurro-Hittite Hymn to Ishtar. Journal of the American Oriental Society 103/1, 155–164.

Haas, V. 1994: Geschichte der hethitischen Religion (HdO 15). Leiden–New York–Köln.

Haas, V. 2003: Betrachtungen zur Traditionsgeschichte hethitischer Rituale am Beispiel des ‘‘Sündenbock’’-Motivs. In G. Beckman et al. (eds.), Hittite Studies in Honor of Harry A.

Hoffner Jr. on the Occasion of His 65th Birthday. Winona Lake, IN, 131–141.

Hoffner, H.A., Melchert, H.C. 2008: A Grammar of the Hittite Language. Pt. 1: Reference Grammar. Winona Lake, IN.

Hutter, M. 2019: The Luwian Rituals of Kuwattalla: thoughts on their re-arrangement. In: A. Süel (ed.). IX. Uluslararası Hititoloji Kongresi Bildirileri, Çorum 08−14 Eylül 2014 − Acts of the IXth International Congress of Hittitology, Çorum, September 08−14, 2014. Çorum, 335–358.

Ivanov, V.A. 2023a: Proishozhdenie rituala Pulisy (CTH 407) [Origin of the Ritual of Puliša (CTH 407)]. Vostok/Oriens 4, 246–264.

Иванов, В.А. 2023a: Происхождение ритуала Пулисы (CTH 407). Восток/Oriens 4, 246–264.

Ivanov, V.A. 2023b: Hittite ānt- and related lexemes. Vostok (Oriens) 6, 42–51.

Josephson, F. 1979: Anatolien tarpa/i-, etc. In: Florilegium anatolicum. Mélanges offerts à Emmanuel Laroche. Paris, 177–184.

Kassian, A.S. 2000: Two Middle Hittite Rituals Mentioning fZiplantawija, Sister of the Hittite King mTuthalija II/I. Moscow.

Kloekhorst, A. 2008: Etymological Dictionary of the Hittite Inherited Lexicon. Leiden.

Kümmel, H.M. 1967: Ersatzrituale für den hethitischen König (StBoT 3). Wiesbaden.

Melchert, H.C., Yakubovich, I. 2022: New Luwian verbal endings of the first person plural. Incontri Linguistici 45, 9–25.

Melchert, H.C. 1988: Luwian Lexical Notes. Historische Sprachforschung 101, 211–243.

Melchert, H.C. 2003: The Luwians (HdO I/68). Leiden–Boston.

Melchert, H.C. 2014: Hittite nakku(wa)- ‘(spirits of) the dead’. In: H.C. Melchert et al. (eds.). Munus amicitiae – Norbert Oettinger a collegis et amicis dicatum. Ann Arbor–New York, 219–227.

Miller, J.L. 2004: Studies in the Origins, Development and Interpretation of the Kizzuwatna Rituals (StBoT 46). Wiesbaden.

Mouton, A. 2010: Hittite Witchcraft. In A. Süel (Ed.). 7 Hit Congr VII. Uluslararası Hititoloji Kongresi Bildirileri, Çorum 25−31 Ağustos 2008 − Acts of the VIIth International Congress of Hittitology, Çorum, August 25−31, 2008. Ankara, 515–528.

Mouton, A. 2014: Rituels de ‘boucs émissaires’ en Anatolie hittite. In: P. Mouton, A., Yakubovich I. 2021: Where did one speak luwili? Geographic and linguistic diversity of Luwian cuneiform texts. Journal of Language Relationship 19/1-2, 25–53.

Neu E. 1990: Zum hurritischen Verbum. Orientalia, 59, 2. Gedenkschrift Einar von Schuler (28.10.1930 – 15.2.1990), 223–233.

Puértolas Rubio, L. 2023: Deities and Impurity in the Puriyanni and Kuwattalla traditions. In I. Yakubovich, A. Mouton (eds.). Luwili. Hittite-Luwian ritual texts attributed to Puriyanni, Kuwattalla and Šilalluḫi (CTH 758–763). Vol. II: Discussion and glossary. With a contribution by Laura Puértolas Rubio (StBoT 72). Wiesbaden, 364–386.

Puhvel, J. 1984: Hittite Etymological Dictionary. Vol. 1: Words beginning with A. Berlin–New York–Amsterdam.

Puhvel, J. 2007: Hittite Etymological Dictionary. Vol. 7: Words beginning with N. Berlin–New York.

Richter, T. 2012: Bibliographisches Glossar des Hurritischen. Wiesbaden.

Sasseville, D. 2020: Anatolian Verbal Stem Formation. Luwian, Lycian and Lydian (BSIEL 21). Leiden–Boston.

Singer, I. 2002: Hittite prayers (WAW 11). Atlanta.

Soysal, O. 2004: On Hittite (LÚ) Ānt- “(The) Equal (one) > Rival” Again. Journal of Ancient Near Eastern Religions 4, 99–105.

Starke, F. 1985: Die keilschrift-luwischen Texte in Umschrift (StBoT 30). Wiesbaden.

Starke, F. 1990: Untersuchungen zur Stammbildung des keilschrift-luwischen Nomens (StBoT 31). Wiesbaden.

Steitler, C.W. 2017: The Solar Deities of Bronze Age Anatolia. Studies in Texts of the Early Hittite Kingdom (StBoT 62). Wiesbaden.

Taracha (ed.). Proceedings of the 8th International Congress of Hittitology, September 5–9, 2011. Warsaw, 558–587.

Taracha, P. 2000: Ersetzen und Entsühnen. Das mittelhethitische Ersatzritual für den Großkönig Tuthalija (CTH *488.4) und verwandte Texte (CHANE 5). Leiden–Boston–Köln.

Tischler, J. 1993: Hethitisches Etymologisches Glossar. Teil 3, T,D/2 (IBS 20). Innsbruck.

Tischler, J. 2001: Hethitisches Handwörterbuch: mit dem Wortschatz der Nachbarsprachen (IBS 102). Innsbruck.

Torri, G. 2003: La similtudine nella magia analogica ittita (StudAs 2).

Tropper, J. 1993: Die Inscriften von Zincirli. Münster.

van Brock, N. 1959: Substitution rituelle. Revue Hittite et Asianique 65, 117–139.

van den Hout, Th. 2020: A History of Hittite Literacy. Writing and Reading in Late Bronze-Age Anatolia (1650−1200 BC). Cambridge.

Yakubovich, I., Mouton, A. 2023a: Luwili. Hittite-Luwian ritual texts attributed to Puriyanni, Kuwattalla and Šilalluḫi (CTH 758–763). Vol. I: Edition and commentary. In cooperation with Laura Puértolas Rubio (StBoT 72). Wiesbaden.

Yakubovich, I., Mouton, A. 2023b: Luwili. Hittite-Luwian ritual texts attributed to Puriyanni, Kuwattalla and Šilalluḫi (CTH 758–763). Vol. II: discussion and glossary. With a contribution by Laura Puértolas Rubio (StBoT 72). Wiesbaden.

Yakubovich, I. 2002: Nugae Luvicae. In: V. Shevoroshkin, P. Sidwell (eds.), Anatolian Languages. Canberra, 189–209.

Yakubovich, I. 2021: The Anatolian Connections of the Greek God Enyalius. In: M. Bianconi (ed.), Linguistic and Cultural Interactions between Greece and Anatolia. In Search of the Golden Fleece. Leiden–Boston, 233–245.

Yakubovich, I. 2022: Peoples and Languages. In: S. de Martino (ed.), Handbook Hittite Empire. Power Structures (Empires through the Ages in Global Perspective 1). Oldenbourg, 3–44.

Zatelli, L. 1998: The Origin of the Biblical Scapegoat Ritual: The Evidence of Two Eblaitic Texts. Vetus Testamentum 48, 254–263.

download PDF

Abstract

Note IV publishes several new graffiti of Berezan, Olbia and its chora, especially homemade amulets. Note V provides an overview of some publications on graffiti from the same centers, including recent articles by the author. Note VI is dedicated to a long-known inscription from the 3rd century BC on a lead plate, which some scholars considered slander, others, including the author, considered a private letter. Recently A.V. Belousov actively developed the first point of view. The author of these notes refutes Belousov’s arguments in detail and provides evidence that this letter is connected with the vicissitudes of a certain process. Philological note VII is dedicated to the mysterious poet of the archaic era Margites and his poem of the same name, which parodies the Homeric epic. Based on the evidence of Plato, the author rejects what has been common since the 4th century BC until Late Antiquity, the opinion about the fool Margites comes to the conclusion that Margites “the fool” is a pseudonym that parodies the common epithets of Homer “wise”, “wise poet”.

Keywords

Berezan island, Olvia Pontica and its chora, graffiti, revision, private letter, Margites.

Valeriy P. Yaylenko

Independent researcher, Moscow, Russia

E-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Audollent, A. 1904: Defixionum tabellae quotquot innotuerunt. Paris. Belousov, A.V. 2017a: To the new edition of the Olbian curse inscription IGDOP 109. In: N.N. Kazanskiy (ed.), Indoeuropeiskoe yazykoznanie i klassicheskaya filologia-XXI [Indo- European linguistics and classical philology – XXI]. Sankt Petersburg, 48–62. Belousov, A.V. 2017b: Novoe grecheskoe zaklyatie iz Nikonia [A new Greek curse inscription from Nikonion]. Aristaeas 16, 55–64. Belousov, A.V. 2020: Korpus zakliatiy pontiyskoy Olvii [Corpus of the curse inscriptions from Olbia Pontica]. Moscow. Blanco Cesteros, M. 2018: El complejo mundo de la retórica mágica: una mirada más allá de la coacción. In: Cuadernos de Filología Clásica. Estudios griegos e indoeuropeos 28. Madrid, 171–193. Blavatskiy, V.D. 1957: Nadpis’ na oblomke fasosskoy amfory [Inscription on the Thasian amphora fragment]. In: Numizmaticheskiy sbornik [Collected articles in Numismatics]. Moscow, 32–33. Boardman, J. 1968: Archaic Greek Gems. Evanston. Bravo, B. 1987: Une tablette magique d’ Olbia Pontique, les morts, les héros et les demons. In M. Détienne et autres (éds.), Poikilia. Études off ertes à J.–P. Vernant (Recherches d’ histoire et des sciences sociales, 26). Paris, 185–218. Bravo, B. 2021: Pontica Varia. Athènes. Cauer, P., Schwyzer E. 1960: Dialectorum Graecarum exempla epigraphica potiora. Hildesheim. Chantraine, P. 1974: Dictionnaire étymologique de la langue grecque. T. 3. Paris. Chistov, D. V. 2007: Novyy complex s pozharischchem vtoroy poloviny VI veka [New complex with fire site of the second half of the 6th century BC]. In: A.I. Aybabin (ed.), Drevnosti Severnogo Prichernomoriya [Antiquities of the ancient North Pontic region]. Simferopol, 127–151. Chistov, D. 2019: Investigations on Berezan Island in 2014-2018 (Hermitage Museum Archaeological Expedition). Hyperboreus 25/1, 97–106. Chistov, D., Pavlichenko, N. 2019: Lead Letter from the Excavations of Area ‘O-Western’ at the Berezan Settlement in 2017. Hyperboreus 25/2, 259–277. Christ, W. 1890: Geschichte der griechischen Litteratur. München. Crönert, G. 1903: Memoria Graeca Herculanensis. Lipsiae. Diehl, E. 1915: A bowl with the curse inscription from Olbia. In: Izvestiya Imperatorskoy Arkheologicheskoy Komissii [Proceedings of the Imperial Archaeological Commission] 58, 40–56. Dubois, L. 1996: Inscriptions grecques dialectales d’Olbia du Pont. Genève. Dufault, O. 2017: Who Wrote Greek Curse Tablets? Humanities Commons: hcommons.org/ deposits. Efremow, N., Snytkó, I. 2004: Altgriechische Keramikstempel von den Ausgrabungen in der Wasserscheide Siversov Majak bei Olbia. Münstersche Beiträge zu antiken Handelsgeschichte XXIII/2, 1–46. Farmakovskiy, B.V. 1926: Raskopki v Olvii v 1925 godu [Excavations at Olbia in 1925]. Soobshcheniya gosudarstvennoy Akademii istorii materialnoy kultury [Communications of the State Academy of Material Culture History] 1, 171–192. Gardthausen, V. 1913: Griechische Palaeographie. Leipzig. Bd. 2. Guarducci, M. 1975: Epigrafia greca. T. 3. Roma. Guarducci, M. 1987: L’epigrafia greca dalle origini al tardo impero. Roma. Hoff mann, O. 1898: Die Griechischen Dialekte. Bd. 3. Göttingen. Hanter, R. 2006: Theocritus and the Archaeology of Greek Poetry. Cambridge. Jeff ery, L. H. 1969: The local scripts of archaic Greece. Oxford. Kibalchich, T.V. 1910: Yuzhnorusskie gemmy [Gems from the South Russia]. Berlin. Kretschmer, P. 1894: Die griechischen Vaseninschriften. Gütersloh. Mayser, E. 1923: Grammatik der griechischen Papyri aus der Ptolemäerzeit. Berolini, Lipsiae. Mikhaylov, A.D. 1976: Franzuzskiy rytsarskiy roman [A French tale of chivalry]. Moscow. Neverov, O. Ya. 1979: Gnosticheskie gemmy, perstni i amulet yuga SSSR [The Gnostic gems, rings and amulets from the South regions of the USSR]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 1, 95–103. Niederle, G. 1880: Sintaxis grecheskogo yasyka [A Syntax of Greek language]. Pt. 2. Moscow. Pape, W., Benseler, G. E. 1884: Wörterbuch der griechischen Eigennamen. Braunschweig. Pavlichenko, N.A., Chistov, D.V. 2020: Kiliki Pifeya i Deynona iz raskopok Beresani i ikh archeologicheskiy context [The Pytheas’ and Deinon’s culices from the excavations at Beresan Island and their archeological context]. Materialy po arkheologii i istorii antichnogo i srednevekovogo Severnogo Prichernomoriya [Proceedings in Archaeology and History of Ancient and Medieval Black Sea Region] 12, 887–913. Polinskaya, I. 2020: Novoe po onomastike Berezani po dannym graffiti iz raskopok 2010 goda [New data on Berezanian onomastics according graffiti from the 2010 excavations]. In D.V. Chistov et al. (eds.). Materialy Berezanskoy (Nizhnebugskoy) antichnoy arkheologicheskoy expeditsii. [Materials of the Berezanian (Low Bug-river) archaeological expedition]. Vol. 3. Sankt Petersburg, 198–204. Polinskaya, I. 2021: Inscribed ceramic bowls and other curses from classical and Hellenistic Olbia. In.: A. Faraone, I. Polinskaya (eds.), Curses in Context III: Greek Curse Tablets of the Classical and Hellenistic Periods. Athens, 135–204. Preisigke, F. 1922: Namenbuch enthaltend alle griechischen, lateinischen ... Menschennamen. Heidelberg. Rusyaeva, A.S. 2010: Graffiti Ol’vii Pontiiskoy [The Graffiti of Olbia Pontica]. Simferopol. Shebalin, N.V. 1968: K ol’viyskim gosudarstvennym drevnostyam [To the Olbian state antiquities]. In: V.F. Gaydukevich (ed.), Antichnaya istoriya i kultura Sredizemnomorya i Prichernomorya [An ancient history and culture of the Mediterranean and Pontic areas]. Leningrad, 296–299. Shevoroshkin, V.V. 1965: Issledovaniya po deshifrovke kariyskikh nadpisey [Studies in decipherment of the Carian inscriptions]. Moscow. Shkorpil, V.V. 1908: Tri svinzovye plastinki s nadpisyami iz Olvii [Three inscribed lead plaques from Olbia]. In: Izvestiya Arkheologicheskoy Komissii [Proceedings of Archaeological Commission]. Sankt Petersburg 27, 68–74. Slovar starofrantsuzskogo yazyka 1955 – V.F. Shishmarev (ed.). Slovar starofrantsuzskogo yazyka [A lexicon of the Old French language]. Moscow–Leningrad. Snytko, I.A. 2019: Olviyskiy polis na rubezhe V i IV vekov v kontexte problem sotsialno-demograficheskogo i administrativno-territorialnogo deleniya [Olbian polis near end of the 5th and beginning of the 4th century in context of the problems of social-demographic and administrative-territorial arrangement]. Chersonesskiy sbornik [Chersonesus Collection] 20, 197–214. Sobolevskiy, S.I. (eds.) 1946: Istoria grecheskoy literatury [A History of Greek Literature]. Vol. 1. Moscow–Leningrad. Solkin, V.V. 2005: Drevniy Egipet [Ancient Egypt]. Moscow. Solovyev, S.L. (ed.) 2005: Borisfen ‒ Berezan’. Arkheologicheskaya kollektsiya Ermitazha [Borysthenes – Berezan Island. Archaeological Collection in the Hermitage]. Vol. 1. Saint Petersburg. Solomonik, E.I. (ed.). 1978: Graffiti antichnogo Chersonesa [The graffiti of Ancient Chersonesus]. Kiev. Soyter, G. 1961: Griechische Humor von Homers Zeiten bis Heute. Kulturgeschichtlich interessante Texte aus drei Jahrtausendenr. Berlin. Stern, E. R. 1897: «Graffiti» na antichnykh yuzhno-russkikh sosudakh [«Graffiti» on ancient South-Russian vessels. Zapiski Odesskogo obshchestva istorii i drevnostey [Notes of the Odessa Society for History and Antiquities] 20, 163–203. Stern, E. R. 1901: Novyi epigraficheskiy material, naydennyi na yuge Rossii [New epigraphical material from the South Russia]. Zapiski Odesskogo obshchestva istorii i drevnostey [Notes of the Odessa Society for History and Antiquities] 23, 1–32. Thumb, A., Kieckers, E. 1932: Handbuch der griechischen Dialekte. Bd. 1. Heidelberg. Thumb, A., Scherer, A. 1959: Handbuch der griechischen Dialekte. Bd. 2. Heidelberg. Tolstoy, I.I. 1951: Narodnoe proiznoshenie v keramicheskoy epigrafike Severnogo Prichernomoriya [Popular pronunciation according data of ceramic epigraphy]. Proceedings of the Literature and Linguistics Department of the Academy of Sciences of USSR Х/4, 374–378. Tolstoy, I.I. 1953: Grecheskie graffiti drevnikh gorodov Severnogo Prichernomoriya [Greek graffiti of the ancient cities of the North Black Sea Region]. Leningrad. Wünsch, R. 1897. Defixionum tabellae in Attica regionem repertae. Berolini (Corpus inscriptionum Atticarum. Vol. III, 3. Appendix). Yaylenko, V.P. 1980a: Graffiti Levki, Berezani i Ol’vii [Graffiti of Leucos, Olbia and Berezan]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 2, 72–99. Yaylenko, V.P. 1980b: Graffiti Levki, Berezani i Ol’vii [Graffiti of Leucos, Olbia and Berezan]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 3, 75–116. Yaylenko, V.P. 1982: Grecheskaya kolonizatsiya VII‒III vekov do nashey ery v epigraficheskikh istochnikakh [A Greek colonization of the 7th‒3rd centuries BC according to the epigraphical sources]. Moscow. Yaylenko, V.P. 1987: Neskolko grecheskikh graffiti i “sarmatskaya” nadpis s Berezani [Some Greek graffiti and “Sarmatian” inscription from Berezan island]. In: L.A. Gindin (ed.), Antichnaya balkanistika [Ancient Balcanistics]. Moscow, 147–154. Yaylenko, V.P. 1998: Chelovek v antichnoy Olvii (ocherk sozialnoy istorii) [A man in ancient Olbia (essay in social history)]. In: L.P. Marinovich (ed.), Chelovek i obshchestvo v antichnom mire [A man and society in the Classical World]. Moscow, 91–130. Yaylenko, V.P. 2005: Magicheskie nadpisi Bospora [The magical inscriptions of the Bosporus]. Drevnosti Bospora [Antiquities of the Bosporus] 8, 459–508. Yaylenko, V.P. 2006: Posvyatitelnye graffiti Pantikapeya i okrugi [The dedicatory graffiti from Pantikapaion and its suburbs]. Drevnosti Bospora [Antiquities of the Bosporus] 9, 355–428. Yaylenko, V.P. 2010: Tysyacheletniy Bosporskiy reikh. Istoriya i epigrafika Bospora VI veka do nashey ery ‒ V veka nashey ery [A Thousand-year Bosporan Reich. A History and Epigraphy of the Bosporus in the 6th c. BC ‒ 5th c. AD]. Moscow. Yaylenko, V.P. 2017: Istoriya i epigrafika Ol’vii, Chersonesa i Bospora VII veka do nashey ery ‒ VI veka nashey ery [A history and epigraphy of Olbia, Chersonesus and the Bosporus of the 7th c. BC ‒ 6th c. AD]. Sankt Petersburg. Yaylenko, V.P. 2018: Istoriografiya i metodika raboty s drevnegrecheskimi graffiti [A historiography and methods of ancient Greek graffiti study]. Materialy po arkheologii i istorii antichnogo i srednevekovogo Kryma [Proceedings in Archaeology and History of the Ancient and Medieval Crimea] 10, 479–516 (electronic resource). Yaylenko, V.P. 2019: Epigraficheskie zametki [The epigraphical notes]. Bosporskie issledovaniya [Bosporos studies] 39, 117–209. Yaylenko, V.P. 2020a: Datirovanie i interpretatsia nadpisei Severnogo Prichernomoria IV–I vekov do n.e. , preimuschestvenno nagovorov i pisem [Dating and interpretation of inscriptions from the North Pontic Region, mainly the curse tablets and private letters]: https://www. academia.edu/48906817. Also see the web-site of Yaroslavl State University: http://elar.uniyar.ac.ru/jspui/bitstream/123456789/3683/1/Yaylenko_Datirovanie.pdf. Also the website: https://www.koob.ru/yajlenko_v_p/datirovanie_tekstologiya_interpretaciya. Yaylenko, V.P. 2020b: Stikhotvornye graffiti Bospora, Olvii, Berezani [The versed graffiti from Bosporus, Olbia, Berezan]. Drevnosti Bospora [Antiquities of the Bosporus] 25, 441–510. Yaylenko, V.P. 2020c: Zametki o tekstologii i datirovanii novoizdannykh nagovorov iz ellinisticheskoy Ol’vii [The notes on text criticizm and dating of the newly published curse inscriptions from Olbia]. Problemy istorii, filologii, kul’tury [Journal of Historical, Philological and Cultural Studies] 4, 24–40. Yaylenko, V.P. 2021: Novaya kniga o nagovorakh Olvii [A new book on the curse inscriptions from Olbia Pontica]. Problemy istorii, filologii, kul’tury [Journal of Historical, Philological and Cultural Studies] 4, 296–311. Yaylenko, V.P. 2022a: Reviziya graffiti Bospora, Chersonesa, Olvii, Berezani iz publikatsiy E.R. Shterna, I.I. Tolstogo, GLBO, svodov GAKh, GOP i dr. [Revision of the graffiti publications by E.R. Stern, I.I. Tolstoy, GLBO, corpuses GAKh, GOP etc. P. 1–112. Also see the web-site of Saratov State University: https://www.sgu.ru/sites/default/files/textdocsfiles/2022/08/17/yaylenko_2022_reviziya_na_sayt_sgu1.pdf. Yaylenko, V.P. 2022b: Zametki k svodam olviyskikh graffiti [Notes to the publications of the Olbian graffiti]. In: A.P. Medvedev (ed.), «Ot Kavkaza do Dunaya». Severnoe Prichernomor’e v antichnuyu epohu. Sbornik nauchnyh trudov k 70-letiyu professora S.Yu. Monahova [“From the Caucasus to the Danube”. Northern Black Sea region in Antiquity. Collection of papers for the 70th anniversary of Professor S.Yu. Monakhov]. Saratov, 447–495. Yaylenko, V.P. 2022c: Dannye arkhiva Odesskogo arkheologicheskogo muzeya o graffiti Berezani i Olvii [The data of archive of Odessa archeological museum on the graffiti from Berezan island and Olbia]. Web-site of Saratov State University: https://www.sgu.ru/sites/default/files/textdocsfiles/2022/02/15/yaylenko_v.p._2022_arhiv_oam.pdf Yaylenko, V P. 2022d: Reviziya izdannykh graffiti Chersonesa [Revision of the published graffiti from Chersonesos]. Chersonesskiy sbornik [Chersonesus Collection] 23, 223–245. Yaylenko, V.P. 2023: Novye drevnegrecheskie sakralnye graffiti i dipinti ostrova Berezan [New ancient Greek sacral graffiti from Berezan island]. In: E.S. Danilov (ed.), Sacralnyy mir ostrovnykh soobshschestv bronzovogo i zheleznogo vekov [The sacral world of the insular societies of the Bronze and Iron Ages]. Yaroslavl, 87–113. Yaylenko, V.P. 2023a: Tekstologiya, paleografiya, istoricheskaya perspektiva novoizdannogo pozdneellinisticheskogo nagovora iz Olvii [Text criticism, paleography, historical perspective of the newly published late Hellenistic curse inscription from Olbia Pontica]. Problemy istorii, filologii, kul’tury [Journal of Historical, Philological and Cultural Studies] 3, 129–162.

download PDF

Abstract

The paper discuses 113 coins retrieved during the 2019–2022 archaeological excavations at the ancient site of “Settlement”, located 0.6 km west of the western outskirts of the village of Starotitarovskaya (Temryuk district of the Krasnodar Territory) in. The coins constitute a reliable numismatic profile of the region, and also reflect the various periods of tension in the life of the settlement. Generally, the numismatic material from “Settlement” covers the timespan from the 5th century BC to the turn of the 2nd/1st centuries BC. The greatest intensity of life, judging by the numismatic material, falls on the last third of the 4th to the mid-3rd century BC. 70 coins have come down from this time. Then the decline lasted in the second half of the 3rd to the 2nd and 1st centuries BC: no coins came from the second half of the 3rd century BC, while 40 coins are dated to 2nd century BC. Two coins date from the reign of Mithridates VI. Thus, numismatic materials clarify the phases of the functioning of the settlement at the station. Starotitarovskaya, life on which apparently ceased at the very beginning of the 1st century BC.

Keywords

Cimmerian Bosporus, Taman peninsula, “Settlement” site near Starotitarovskaya, excavation coins, currency.

Mikhail G. Abramzon, Institute of Archaeology, Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia; Nosov Magnitogorsk State Technical University, Magnitogorsk, Russia, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Andrey B. Kolesnikov, Institute of Archaeology, Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Abramzon, M.G., Karpov, D.A., Kolesnikov, A.B. 2021: Monety iz raskopok antichnogo poseleniya Vyshesteblievskaya 3 v 2017‒2018 gg. [Coins from the excavations at the ancient settlement of Vyshesteblievskaya 3 in 2017–2018]. In: V.N. Zinko, E.A. Zinko (eds.), Bospor Kimmerijskiy i varvarskiy mir v period antichnosti i srednevekov’ya. Novye otkrytiya, novye proekty. Materialy mezhdunarodnoy konferentsii [The Cimmerian Bosporus and Barbarian World in the Period of Antiquity and the Middle Ages. New Discoveries, New Projects. Materials of the International Conference] (ΧΧΙΙ Bosporskie chteniya [Bosporan Readings]). Simferopol‒Kerch, 10–17.

Abramzon, M.G., Barinov, D.G., Kolesnikov, A.B. 2023: Monety iz raskopok antichnogo poseleniya Chekups-2 (2018–2019 gg.) [Coins from 2018–2019 Excavations at the Settlement of Chekups 2 (The Krasnodar Territory)]. Problemy istorii, filologii, kul’tury [Journal of Historical, Philological and Cultural Studies] 3, 197–217.

Abramzon, M.G., Zavoykin, A.A., Sudarev, N.I. 2016: Monety iz raskopok antichnogo poseleniya “Beregovoy 4” (1987, 1988, 1999–2002 gg.) [Coins from excavations of the ancient settlement of Beregovoy 4 in 1987–1988 and 1999–2002]. Drevnosti Bospora [Antiquities of the Bosporus] 20, 11‒34.

Anokhin, V.A. 1986: Monetnoe delo Bospora [Coinage of the Bosporus]. Kiev.

Berezina, N.Ya., Abramova, A.N., Ziganshin, R.Kh., Ivanov, A.V. 2023: Novye sluchai skal’pirovaniya iz mogil’nikov Predkavkaz’ya i Severnogo Kavkaza v epokhu rannego zheleznogo veka [New cases of scalping from the burial grounds of the Pre-Caucasus and the North Caucasus in the Early Iron Age]. Arkheologiya Evraziyskikh stepey [Archaeology of the Eurasian Steppes] 6, 283‒296.

Paromov, Ya.M. 1992: Arkheologicheskaya karta Tamanskogo poluostrova [Archaeological Map of the Taman Peninsula]. Moscow.

Shelov, D.B. 1956: Monetnoe delo Bospora VI‒II vv. do n.e. [Coinage of the Bosporus 6th –2nd centuries BC]. Moscow.

Sheremetyev, A.G. 2020: Otchet o raskopkakh Poseleniya v 0,6 km k zapadu ot zapadnoy okrainy stanitsy Starotitarovskaya Temryukskogo rayona Krasnodarskogo kraya v 2019 godu [Report on the excavations at the Settlement 0.6 km west of the western outskirts of the village of Starotitarovskaya, Temryuk district, Krasnodar Territory, in 2019]. Vol. I‒VI. Saratov. Archive of the Institute of Archaeology, Russian Academy of Sciences. No. 64283– 64288.

Shevchenko, N.F. 2023: Otchet po rezul’tatam issledovaniy (nablyudenie) na territorii vyyavlennykh ob’ektov arkheologicheskogo naslediya “Poselenie”, 0,6 km k zapadu ot zapadnoy okrainy st. Starotitarovskoy, “Poselenie”, 6.2 km k zapadu-severo-zapadu ot kladbishcha st. Starotitarovskoy, v zone rekonstruktsiy avtomobil’noy dorogi A290 Novorossiysk – Kerch’ na uchastke km 73 – km 100 (1etap) avtomobil’naya doroga M-25 Novorossiysk – Kerch’ (na Simferopol’), pod’ezdy k morskim portam Kavkaz i Taman’ v Temryukskom rayone Krasnodarskogo kraya [Report on the results of research (observation) on the territory of the identified objects of archaeological heritage “Settlement”, 0.6 km west of the western outskirts of the stanitsa of Starotitarovskaya, “Settlement”, 6.2 km westnorthwest of the cemetery of the stanitsa Starotitarovskaya, in the reconstruction zone of the A290 Novorossiysk – Kerch highway on the section km 73 - km 100 (1st stage) M-25 Novorossiysk – Kerch highway (to Simferopol), approaches to the seaports of Kavkaz and Taman in the Temryuk district of the Krasnodar Territory]. Vol. 1. Krasnodar.

download PDF

Abstract

Eighty-two coins were found during the 2018 excavations at a site located near the Church of St. John the Baptist, Kerch: 50 are Bosporan, 2 Roman, 18 Byzantine, one Italian, 2 Crimean 16th c., 4 Russian 18th‒20th cc., 4 unidentifiable. Strongly worn staters of Thothorses to Rhescuporis VI were circulated in the 6th–7th centuries together with synchronous Byzantine coins (those of Maurice, Heraclius, Justinian Ι, and Constans ΙΙ were retrieved in the excavation trench). No Byzantine coins came from the 8th–10th centuries. The second portion of Byzantine coins consists of the tenth-century issues (Constantine VII, Roman II, and Basil II). The mint of Cherson dominates. Of great interest is a rare denarius of Landulf of Conza struck in Salerno in 973. Couple akche of the 16th century Crimean khans are the latest coins in the collection. The isolated late Bosporan staters and medieval coins constitute a reliable numismatic profile for Bosporus (Kerch) — evidence of the coin circulation in the city and the region mainly from the fourth to the sixteenth century. The profile is similar to coins finds from a number of twen tiethcentury excavation areas around the Church of St. John the Baptist, and other including those of the Late Roman, Byzantine and Ottoman periods.

Keywords

Bosporus (Kerch), excavation 2018, Early Byzantine period, Ottoman period, excavation coins, currency.

Mikhail G. Abramzon, Institute of Archaeology, Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia; Nosov Magnitogorsk State Technical University, Magnitogorsk, Russia, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Vadim V. Mayko, Institute of Archaeology of Crimea, Russian Academy of Sciences, Simferopol, Russia, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Svetlana A. Kononova, Crimean Regional Center for Archaeological Research LLC, Simferopol, Russia, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Leonid Yu. Ponomarev, Institute of Archaeology of Crimea, Russian Academy of Sciences, Simferopol, Russia, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Abramzon, M.G., Kuznetsov, V.D. 2017: Klad pozdnebosporskikh staterov iz Fanagorii [The hoard of late Bosporan staters from Phanagoria] (Fanagoriya. Rezul’taty arkheologicheskikh issledovaniy [Phanagoria. Results of Archaeological Research], 5). Moscow.

Abramzon, M.G., Novichikhin, A.M., Saprykina, I.A., Smekalova, T.N., 2019: Tretiy Gay- Kodzorskiy klad pozdnebosporskikh staterov [The Third Hoard of Late Bosporan Staters from the Gai-Kodzor Site]. Moscow.

Anokhin, V.A. 1986: Monetnoe delo Bospora [Coinage of the Bosporus]. Kiev.

Aybabin, A.I. 2000. Khazarskiy sloy v Kerchi [Khazar layer in Kerch]. Materialy po arkheologii, istorii i etnografii Taurii [Materials on Archaeology, History and Ethnography of Tauria] VII, 168‒185.

Aybabin, A.I., Khayredinova, E.A. 2015: Plitovye mogily s vysechennymi krestami iz rannesrednevekovogo mogil’nika Bospora [Slab graves with carved crosses in an early medieval Bosporan burial ground]. Bosporkie issledovaniya [Bosporos Studies] XXXI, 354‒378.

Aybabin, A.I., Khayredinova, E.A. 2018: Rannevizantiyskiy nekropol’ Bospora [An Early Byzantine necropolis of Bosporus]. Antichnaya drevnost’ i srednie veka [Antiquity and the Middle Ages] 46, 33‒53.

Frolova, N.А. 1997: Monetnoe delo Bospora (seredina I v do n.e. – seredina IV v. n.e.) [The Coinage of the Bosporus (the mid-1st century BC – mid-4th century AD)]. 2 vols. Moscow.

Golenko, K.V. 1970: Monety, naydennye pri raskopkakh v Kerchi v 1964 g. [Coin finds in the excavations at Kerch in 1964]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 2, 87–99.

Golenko, K.V., Shelov, D.B. 1963: Monety iz raskopok Pantikapeya 1945–1961 gg. [Coin from 1945–1961 excavations at Panticapaeum]. Numizmatika i sfragistika [Numismatics and Sphragistics] 1, 3–65.

Goncharov, E.Yu., Chkhaidze, V.N. 2018: Monety iz raskopok 1971 g. u khrama Ioanna Predtechi v Kerchi [Coins from the 1971 excavation near the Church of St. John the Baptist, Kerch]. In: “PriPONTiyskiy menyala: den’gi mestnogo rynka”. V Mezhdunarodnyy numizmaticheskiy simpozium (Moskva, 20–21.09. 2018 g.). Materialy nauchnoy konferentsii [“Pontic Money-Changer: Money of the Local Market.” Vth International Numismatic Symposium (Moscow, September 20–21, 2018). Scientific Conference Materials]. Simferopol‒ Moscow, 37–38.

Grierson, Ph., Travaini, L. 1998: Medieval European Coinage. Vol. 14. Italy (III). South Italy, Sicily, Sardinia: With a Catalogue of the Coins in the Fitzwilliam Museum (Medieval European Coinage, Series Number 14). Cambridge.

Ivanina, O.A., Kulikov, A.V., Kkolodkov, V.N. 2006: Vizantiyskie monety VI‒VII vv. v sobranii Kerchenskogo zapovednika (k istorii denezhnogo obrashcheniya v Tavrike v epokhu rannego srednevekov’ya) [The 6th–7th centuries Byzantine coins in the Kerch Reserve (on the history of currency in Taurica in the early Middle Ages)]. In: Nauchnyy sbornik Kerchenskogo zapovednika. Vyp. I. K 180-letiyu Kerchenskogo muzeya drevnostey [Scientific Collection of the Kerch Reserve. Vol. I. To the 180th Anniversary of the Kerch Museum of Antiquities]. Kerch, 149–171.

Kononova, S.A., Mayko, V.V., Ponomarev, L.Yu. 2024b: Kompleksy VII v. rannevizantiyskogo Bospora (po materialam okhrannykh raskopok 2018 g. v Kerchi k yugo-zapadu ot tserkvi Ioanna Predtechi). Postroyka 2 [Seventh-century complexes of the Early Byzantine Bosporus (based on materials from security excavations in 2018 at Kerch, the Dimitrov Lane). Building 2]. Istoriya i arkheologiya Kryma [History and Archaeology of Crimea] (forthcoming).

Kononova, S.A., Mayko, V.V., Ponomarev, L.Yu. 2024а: Kompleksy VII v. rannevizantiyskogo Bospora (po materialam okhrannykh raskopok 2018 g. v Kerchi v per. Dimitrova). Goncharnaya masterskaya k yugu ot postroyki 2 [Seventh-century complexes of the Early Byzantine Bosporus (based on materials from security excavations in 2018 at Kerch, the Dimitrov Lane). Pottery workshop south of Building 2]. Istoriya i arkheologiya Kryma [History and Archaeology of Crimea] (forthcoming).

Kropotkin, V.V. 1962: Klady vizantiyskikh monet na territorii SSSR [Byzantine Coin Hoards in USSR] (Svod arkheologicheskikh istochnikov [Corpus of Archaeological Sources] E4–4).

Kropotkin, V.V. 1965: Novye nakhodki vizantiyskikh monet na territorii SSSR [Recent Byzantine coin finds in USSR]. Vizantiyskiy vremennik [Byzantine Chronicle] 26, 166–189.

Kropotkin, V.V. 1971: Novye nakhodki vizantiyskikh monet v Kerchi [Recent Byzantine coin finds in Kerch]. Vizantiyskiy vremennik [Byzantine Chronicle] 32, 216–218.

Kropotkin, V.V., Makarova, T.I. 1973: Nakhodka monety Olega-Mikhaila v Korcheve [Coin of Oleg-Mikhail found in Korchev]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya [Soviet Archaeology] 2, 250– 254.

Makarova, T.I. 1998: Arkheologicheskie raskopki v Kerchi okolo tserkvi Ioanna Predtechi [Archaeological excavations near the Church of St. John the Baptist, Kerch]. Materialy po arkheologii, istorii i etnografii Taurii [Materials on Archaeology, History and Ethnography of Tauria] VI, 344–393.

Mayko, V.V. 2014: Vostochnyy Krym vj vtoroy polovine X – XII vv. [Eastern Crimea in the Second Half of the 10th – 12th Century]. Kiev.

Mayko, V.V. 2021a: Saltovo-mayatskie gorizonty Bospora (po materialam raskopok 2018 g.) [Saltovo-Mayaki horizons of Bosporus (based on materials from excavations in 2018)]. In: Mikheevskie chteniya [Mikheev Readings] II. Kharkov, 65–78.

Mayko, V.V. 2021b. Vizantiyskie elementy material’noy kul’tury Bospora XIII–XIV vv. (na primere raskopa 2018 g.) [Byzantine elements of the material culture of Bosporus of the 13th– 14th centuries (the 2018 excavation)]. Antichnaya drevnost’ i srednie veka [Antiquity and the Middle Ages] 49, 176–192.

Mayko, V.V., Sharapa, A.V., Yurochkin, V.Yu., Mikhaylov, A.M. 2021: K voprosu o material’noy kul’ture Bospora vtoroy poloviny X–XII vv. (na primere okhrannykh raskopok 2018 g.) [On the issue of the material culture of Bosporus of the second half of the 10th – 12th centuries (security excavations in 2018)]. Istoriya i arkheologiya Kryma [History and Archaeology of Crimea] XIV. Simferopol, 95‒122.

Naumenko, V.E., Ponomarev, L.Yu. 2013a: Khristianskie pamyatniki i topografiya Bospora X–XII vv. [Christian sites and topography of Bosporus in the 10th–12th centuries]. In: T.Yu. Yashaeva (ed.), Klimentovskiy sbornik. Materialy VI Mezhdunarodnoy konferentsii “Tserkovnaya arkheologiya: Khersones – gorod svyatogo Klimenta” (Sevastopol, 2011 g.) [Kliment Collection. Materials of the VI International Conference “Church Archaeology: Chersonesus, the City of St. Clement” (Sevastopol, 2011)]. Sevastopol, 244–263.

Naumenko, V.E., Ponomarev, L.YU. 2013b: K istoricheskoy topografii Bospora X–XII vv.: ob obstoyatel’stvakh nakhodki i mestopolozhenii tak nazyvaemoy “Tserkvi Sheveleva” (“Tserkvi 1833 g.”) [On the historical topography of Bosporus from the 19th to the 18th centuries: about the circumstances of the find and the location of the so-called “Shevelev Church” (“Church of 1833”)]. In: Ρωμαίος: sbornik statey k 60-letiyu prof. S.B. Sorochana [Ρωμαίος: Miscellany of Articles to the 60th Anniversary of Prof. S.V. Sorochan] (Narteks. Byzantine Ukrainensis, 2). Kharkov, 295–309.

Oikonomides, N. 1972: Les listes de preseance Byzantines des IX et X siecles. Paris.

Ponomarev, L.Yu. 2020: K izucheniyu khristianskikh nekropoley rannevizantiyskogo Bospora (po rezul’tatam okhrannykh raskopok v 1986 g. na ul. Sverdlova v Kerchi) [To the study of Christian necropolises of early Byzantine Bosporus (based on the results of security excavations in 1986 on Sverdlova Street in Kerch)]. In: V.V. Mayko, E.A. Khayredinova, T.Yu. Yashaeva (eds.), Khristianstvo v arkheologicheskikh i pis’mennykh istochnikakh. Materialy IX Mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoy konferentsii po tserkovnoy arkheologii. Sevastopol, 21–25 sentyabrya 2020 g. [Christianity in Archaeological and Written Sources. Materials of the IX International Scientific Conference on Church Archeology. Sevastopol, September 21–25, 2020]. Simferopol, 108–113.

Ponomarev, L.YU., Kononova, S.A., Mayko, V.V. 2023: Okhranno-spasatel’nye raskopki v per. Dimitrova (2018 g.) v kontekste istorii arkheologicheskogo izucheniya i topografii srednevekovoy Kerchi [Security and rescue excavations on Dimitrov lane (2018) in the context of the history of archaeological study and topography of medieval Kerch]. Istoriya i arkheologiya Kryma [History and Archaeology of Crimea] XVIII, 267–297.

Pushkarev, O.V. 2014: O monetakh s legendoy LAN SABAS [Coins with the legend LAN SABAS]. Antichnaya drevnost’ i srednie veka [Antiquity and the Middle Ages] 42, 206‒214.

Retowski, O. 1905: Die Münzen der Gireï. Moskau.

Sharapa, A.V. 2019: Nauchnyy otchet o vypolnenii spasatel’nykh arkheologicheskikh polevykh rabot (arkheologicheskikh nablyudeniy) na uchastke ob”ekta kul’turnogo naslediya federal’nogo znacheniya «Drevnerusskoe gorodishche letopisnogo goroda Korchev» v zone stroitel’stva gostinichnogo kompleksa na zemel’nom uchastke po adresu: Respublika Krym, gorod Kerch’, pereulok Dimitrova, 4 (kadastrovyy nomer 90:19:010109:1940) [Scientific report on the implementation of rescue archaeological field work (archaeological observations) on the site of a cultural heritage site of federal significance “Ancient Russian settlement of the chronicle city of Korchev” in the construction zone of a hotel complex on a land plot at the address: Republic of Crimea, Kerch, Dimitrov lane, 4 (cadastral number 90:19:010109:1940)]. 2 vols. Simferopol.

Shkorpil, V.V. 1914: Otchet o raskopkakh v Kerchi i na Tamanskom poluostrove v 1911 g. [Report on excavations in Kerch and on the Taman Peninsula in 1911]. Izvestiya Imperatorsloy arkheologicheskoy komissii [Proceedings of the Imperial Archaeological Commission] 56, 1–74.

Sidorenko, V.A. 2003: Mednaya chekanka vizantiyskogo Bospora (590–668 gg.) [The Bronze Coinage of Byzantine Bosporus (590–668)]. Materialy po arkheologii, istorii i etnografii Taurii [Materials on Archaeology, History and Ethnography of Tauria] X, 355–392.

Turova, N.P. 2014: Srednevekovyy peshchernyy kompleks khrebta Iograf nad g. Yaltoy [Medieval cave complex of Iograf Ridge over Yalta]. Materialy po arkheologii i istorii antichnogo i srednevekovogo Kryma [Materials in Archaeology and History of Ancient and Medieval Crimea] 6, 93–173.

Uzdenikov, V.V. 2004: Monety Rossii 1700‒1917 [Russian Coins 1700‒1917]. 3rd Ed. Moscow.

download PDF

Abstract

The article presents the results of studying the anthropological material from the 1st – 3rd cc. AD stone crypt excavated in Kerch in 2018. The bones were significantly damaged both in antiquity and during the removal from the burial. Based on the counting of homologous skeletal elements, the minimum number of individuals was established. Basic demographic parameters are calculated. The gender and age composition of the sample suggests that belonging to the same family was not the main criterion for burial in the crypt. The main characteristics of the group find analogies with samples from synchronous burial chamber of Phanagoria.

Keywords

Bosporan kingdom, Roman period, anthropology, gender and age structure, pathologies and anomalies on bones.

Violetta P. Guseva, Institute of Archaeology of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia; Kolomna Archaeological Center, Kolomna, Russia, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Nataliya G. Svirkina, Institute of Archaeology of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Alekseev, V.P. 1966: Osteometriya. Metodika antropologicheskikh issledovaniy [Osteometry. Methodology of anthropologic research]. Moscow.

Alekseeva, T.I., Bogatenkov, D.V., Lebedinskaya, G.V. 2003: Vlakhi. Antropo-ekologicheskoe issledovanie (po materialam srednevekovogo nekropolya Mistikhali) [Vlachs. Anthropoecological study (on the materials of the medieval necropolis of Mistikhali)]. Moscow.

Beylin, D.V., Rukavishnikova, I.V., Fedoseev, N.F. 2023: Issledovaniya kamennogo sklepa v rayone ul. Miroshnika v Kerchi (Severnyy uchastok nekropolya Pantikapeya) [Investigation of the stone crypt in the area of Miroshnika Street in Kerch (Northern section of the necropolis of Panticapaeum)]. Antiquities of the Bosporus 28, 38–61.

Buzhilova, A.P. 1995: Drevnee naselenie (paleopatologicheskie aspekty issledovaniya) [Ancient population (paleopathological aspects of research)]. Moscow.

Dobrovolskaya, M.V. 2016: [Experience of studying skeletal materials from the Roman time crypts in the Eastern necropolis of Phanagoria]. Kratkie soobshcheniya Instituta arkheologii [Brief Communications of the Institute of Archaeology] 244, 299–310.

Gerasimova, M.I., Rud, N.M., Yablonsky, L.T. 1987: Antropologiya antichnogo i srednevekovogo naseleniya Vostochnoy Evropy [Anthropology of the ancient and medieval population of Eastern Europe]. Moscow.

Keenleyside, A., Schwarcz, H., Stirling, L., Lazreg, N.B. 2009: Stable isotopic evidence for diet in a Roman and Late Roman population from Leptiminus, Tunisia. Journal of Archaeological Science 36.1, 51–63.

Mays, S. 2010: Archaeology of Human Bones. Routledge.

Moles, A.A. 2012: Stable Isotope Analysis Study for Dietary Reconstruction at the Multi-Period Site of Mesembria on the Black Sea. MSc Thesis. Edinburgh.

Ognerubov, N.A., Ognerubova, M.A., Stegachev, S.K. 2017: Anomalii grudiny: sudebnomeditsinskoe znachenie [Anomalies of the sternum: forensic significance]. Vestnik Tambovskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta [Bulletin of the Tambov State University] 22.1, 155–163.

Reinberg, S.A. 1965: Rentgenodiagnostika zabolevaniy kostey i sustavov [Radiodiagnosis of diseases of bones and joints]. Moscow.

Rokhlin, D.G. 1965: Bolezni drevnikh lyudey [Diseases of ancient people]. Moscow.

Stanton, G. 1969: The Relation of Diet to Salivary Calculus Formation. Journal of Periodontology 40.3, 167–172.

Svirkina, N.G. 2020: Naselenie Fanagorii v III v. do n.e. – V v. n.e. (po paleoantropologicheskim materialam iz Vostochnogo nekropolya): diss. na soisk. uch. step. kand. ist. nauk [Population of Phanagoria in the 3rd centiry BC – 5th century AD (on paleoanthropological materials from the Eastern necropolis): PhD Text]. Moscow.

Ubelaker, D. 1978: Human skeletal remains. Excavation, analysis, interpretation. Smithsonian Institution. Chicago.

download PDF

Abstract

The article examines Late Archaic Ionian amphorae (“Protothasian”), which were found during excavations at the “Upper City” of Phanagoria in stratified contexts (houses, pits) of the second half of the 6th – the first two decades of the 5th century BC. The main goal of the work was to correlate these amphorae with the current chronological schemes proposed for this group of ceramic containers. The most significant problem here is that “Protothasian” amphorae were produced not in one, but in several Ionian centers. For now, we can only say with certainty that Teos was one of these centers (Kerschner, Mommsen 2022). Recognition of this fact disavows the hypothesis about the nature of the amphora containers of this polis at the end of the 7th – first half of the 6th century BC. (Sezgin 2017). “Protothasian” amphorae in the contexts considered are represented from the founding of Phanagoria (ca. 540 BC) until the destruction of buildings in this area of the city ca. 480 BC. In the earliest contexts (540–530/20 BC) exceptionally large (approx. 20–22 l) pythoid amphorae of the ‘first and second series’ according to the classification of S.Yu. Monakhov (2003; resp. Sezgin, 2012, Ionia β3 and Ionia β1-2). Judging by the amphorae from the storage pit (No. 32) in Patraeus (Abramov 2006), in the last quarter of the 6th century BC amphorae of the ‘second series’ coexist for some time with a new type of “Protothasian” amphorae. They had a smaller volume (approx. 10–14 l) and a diff erent body shape (conical). It was these amphorae of the ‘third series’ (according to: Monakhov 2003) until the turn of the first and second quarters of the 5th century. BC are present in the imports of Phanagoria along with amphorae, which Monakhov classifies as the ‘fourth series’ (their dating is limited to the first quarter / third of the 5th century BC).

Keywords

Phanagoria, Northern Ionia, Teos, “Protothasian” amphorae, classification, chronology, stratigraphy.

Aleksey А. Zavoykin

Institute of Archaeology of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia

E-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Abramov, A.P. 1994: Antichnyye amfory. Periodizatsiya i khronologiya [Ancient amphorae. Periodization and chronology]. Bosporskiy sbornik [Bosporan Collection] 3, 4–135.

Abramov, A.P. 2006: Kompleks amfor posledney chetverti VI v. do n.e. iz Patreya. Drevnosti Bospora [Complex of amphorae of the last quarter of the 6th century BC from Patraeus]. Drevnosti Bospora [Antiquities of the Bosporus] 9, 11–35.

Abramov, A.P. 2009: Amfory VI–V vv. do n.e. v Severnom Prichernomor’ye (klassifikatsiya i periodizatsiya) [Amphorae of the 6th–5th centuries BC at the Northern Black Sea region (classification and periodization)]. Abstract. diss. PhD. Moscow.

Abramov, A.P. 2020: Grecheskiye amfory 6–5 vv. do n.e. v Severnom Prichernomor’ye [Greek amphoras of the 6th–5th centuries BC at the Northern Black Sea region]. Moscow.

Abramov, A.P., Sazonov, Yu.S. 1992: Keramika trekh podvodnykh kompleksov Patreya [Ceramics of the three underwater complexes from Patraeus]. Bosporskiy sbornik [Bosporan Collection] 1, 147–172.

Bîrzescu, Iu. 2012. Die archaischen und früklassischen Transportamphoren (Histria XV). Bucureşti.

Chistov, D. Ye., Ilyina, Yu.I., Yeremeyeva, A.A., Shcherbakova, O.Ye. 2020: Berezanskoye poseleniye v issledovaniyakh 2010–2014 godov [Berezan settlement in the research of 2010–2014] (Materialy Berezanskoy (Nizhnebugskoy) antichnoy arkheologicheskoy ekspeditsii [Materials of the Berezan (Nizhnebug) ancient archaeological expedition] 3). Saint Petersburg.

Chistov, D.Ye. 2022: Kleyma na «protofasosskikh» amforakh v pozdnearkhaicheskikh kontekstakh Berezanskogo poseleniya [Stamps on “Protothasian” amphorae in the Late Archaic contexts of the Berezan settlement]. In: A.P. Medvedev (ed.), “Ot Kavkaza do Dunaya”: Severnoe Prichernomor’e v antichnuyu epokhu. Sbornik nauchnykh trudov v chest’ 70-letiya S.Yu. Monakhova [“From the Caucasus to the Danube”: The Northern Black Sea region in Antiquity. Studies presented to S.Yu. Monakhov on the occasion of his 70th Birthday]. Saratov, 441–450.

Chistov, D.Ye., Zuyev, V.Yu., Ilyina, Yu.I., Kasparov, A.K., Novoselova, N.Yu. 2012: Issledovaniya na ostrove Berezan’ v 2005–2009 gg. [Research on Berezan Island in 2005–2009] (Materialy Berezanskoy (Nizhnebugskoy) antichnoy arkheologicheskoy ekspeditsii [Materials of the Berezan (Nizhnebug) Ancient Archaeological Mission] 2). Saint Petersburg.

Dupont, P. 2018: Erythrai versus South Ionia: «Samian» Amphoras Revisited. In: V.D. Kuznetsov, A.A. Zavoykin (eds.), Materialy po arkheologii i istorii Fanagorii [Materials on the archeology and history of Phanagoria] 3 (Fanagoriya [Phanagoria] 6). Мoscow, 88–100.

Grach, N.L. 1999: Nekropol’ Nimfeya [Necropolis of Nymphaeum]. Saint Petersburg

Kerschner, M., Mommsen, H. 2022: Teos in the Geometric and Archaic Period: a Major Production Centre of Pottery in North Ionia. In: G.R. Tsetskhladze (ed.), Ionians in the West and East (Colloquia Antiqua 27). Leuven–Paris–Bristol, 169–213.

Kuzmina, Yu.N., Kamelina, G.A. 2015: Lepnaya keramika iz raskopok ob’ekta 464 v Fanagorii [Hand-made pottery from excavations at the site #464 at Phanagoria]. Problemy istorii, filologii, kul’tury [Journal of Historical, Philological and Cultural Studies] 1, 316–321.

Kuznetsov, V.D. 2021: Arkhaicheskiye steny Fanagorii [Archaic walls of Phanagoria]. Hypanis 3, 111–130.

Kuznetsova, Ye.V. 2005: Metodika izucheniya antichnoy torgovli (na primere keramicheskogo kompleksa Fanagoriyskogo gorodishcha) [Methodology for studying ancient trade (using the example of the ceramic complex of the Phanagoria city-site)]. Antiquitas Iuventae 1. Saratov, 159–171.

Leipunska, N.O. 1973: Klassifikatsiya amfor akhaichnogo chasu z Ol’vii [Classification of amphorae from the Archaic period from Olbia]. Arkheologiya [Archaeology] 8, 45–58

Lomtadze, G.A. 2005: Amfory s nozhkoy v vide slozhnoprofilirovannogo kol’tsevogo poddona v sobranii Gosudarstvennogo Istoricheskogo muzeya [Amphorae with a foot in the form of a complex-profiled ring tray in the collection of the State Historical Museum]. Bosporskiye issledovaniya [Bosporos Studies] VIII, 318–338.

Monakhov, S.Yu. 2003: Grecheskie amfory v Prichernomor’e: Tipologiya amfor vedushchikh tsentrov-eksporterov tovarov v keram. tare: Katalog-opredelitel’ [Greek Αmphorae in the Black Sea region: Typology of amphorae of the leading centers-exporters of products in ceramic containers: Catalogue]. Moscow–Saratov.

Monachov, S.Ju., Kuznetsova, E.V. 2017: Overseas Trade in the Blacksea Region from the Archaic to the Hellenistic Period. In: V. Kozlovskaya (ed.), The Northern Black Sea in Antiquity. Networks, Connectivity, and Cultural Interaction. Cambridge, 59–99.

Monakhov, S.Yu., Kuznetsova, E.V., Tolstikov, V.P., Churekova, N.B. 2020: Amfory VI–I vv. do n.e. iz sobraniya Gosudarstvennogo muzeya izobrazitel’nykh iskusstv im. A.S. Pushkina [Amphorae of the 6th–1st Centuries BC in the Pushkin State Museum of Fine Arts]. Saratov.

Monakhov, S.Yu., Kuznetsova, Ye.V., Chistov, D.Ye., Churekova, N.B. 2019: Amfornaya kollektsiya Gosudarstvennogo Ermitazha VI–II vv. do n.e. [Amphorae of the 6th–2nd centuries BC in the State Hermitage]. Saratov.

Nicolaidu, I., Empereur, J.-Y. 1986: Amphores rhodiennes du musee de Nicosie. BCH Suppl. XIII, 515–533.

Roberts, S.R. 1986: The Stoa Gutter Well. A Late Archaic Deposit from a Well in the Athenian Agora. Hesperia 55/1, 1–74.

Ruban, V.V. 1991. Opyt klassifikatsii tak nazyvayemykh miletskikh amfor iz Nizhnego Pobuzh’ya [Experience of classification of the so-called Milesian amphorae from the Lower Bug region]. Sovetskaya Arkheologiya [Soviet Arсhaeology] 2, 182–195.

Sezgin, Yu. 2012: Arkaik dönem İonia üretimi ticari amphoralar. İstanbul.

Sezgin, Yu. 2017: Arkaik dönemde Teos’ta ticari amphora üretimi: sorunlar ve gözlemler. Anadolu 43, 15–39.

Zavoykin, A.A. 2018. Amfornyye materialy iz drevneyshego sloya Fanagorii [Amphoric finds from the oldest layer of Phanagoria]. Kratkiye soobshcheniya Instituta arkherologii [Brief Communications of the Institute of Archaeology] 252, 138–152.

Zavoykin, A.A. 2019: Novyye amfornyye kompleksy iz raskopok «Verkhnego goroda» Fanagori [New amphorae complexes from the excavations at the “Upper City” of Phanagoria]. Drevnosti Bospora [Antiquities of the Bosporus] 24, 232–252.

Zavoykin, A.A. 2023. Amfornyy kompleks doma 888 na «Verkhnem gorode» Fanagorii [Amphorae complex of House #888 on the “Upper City” of Phanagoria]. Problemy istorii, filologii, kul’tury [Journal of Historical, Philological and Cultural Studies] 3, 55–68.

Zavoykin, A.A., Chashuk, M.S. 2023: Pozdnearkhaicheskaya yama na «Verkhnem gorode» Fanagorii. (Materialy k datirovke drevneyshey zastroyki) [Late archaic pit on the “Upper City” of Phanagoria. (Materials for the dating of the most ancient buildings)]. Kratkiye soobshcheniya Instituta arkherologii [Brief Communications of the Institute of Archaeology] 271, 69–84.

Zavoykin, A.A., Kolesnikov, A.B., Sudarev, N.I. 2016: Pozdnearkhaicheskiye pogrebeniya na «Yuzhnom gorode» Fanagorii [Late Archaic burials at the “Southern City” of Phanagoria]. In: A.A. Zavoykin (ed.), Materialy po arkheologii i istorii Fanagorii [Materials on the archaeology and history of Phanagoria] 2 (Fanagoriya [Phanagoria] 4). Moscow, 110–207.

Zavoykin, A.A., Kuznetsov, V.D. 2020: Khronologiya arkhaicheskogo doma iz Fanagorii [Chronology of an archaic house at Phanagoria]. Hypanis 2, 129–140.

Zavoykin, A.A., Kuznetsov, V.D. 2023: Fanagoriya v period pozdney arkhaiki – ranney klassiki (stratigrafiya, khronologiya, periodizatsiya. 1) [Phanagoria in the period of the late archaic – early classic (stratigraphy, chronology, periodization. 1)]. Drevnosti Bospora [Antiquities of the Bosporus] 28, 126–148.

Zavoykin, A.A., Kuznetsova, Ye.V., Monakhov, S.Yu. 2013: Sklad amfor 290B iz Fanagorii [Warehouse of amphorae #290B from Phanagoria]. In: V.D. Kuznetsov (ed.), Materialy po istorii i arkheologii Fanagorii [Materials on the history and archaeology of Phanagoria] 1 (Fanagoriya [Phanagoria] 1). Moscow, 226–229.

Zeest, I.B. 1960: Keramicheskaya tara Bospora [Ceramic containers in Bosporus] (Materialy i issledovaniya po arkheologii [Materials and Research on the Archaeology of USSR] 83). Moscow.

download PDF

Abstract

The article presents some observations about the methodological features of the excavations at the necropolis of Phanagoria. This is the most difficult site for excavations on the Asiatic Bosporus. The capital status of the city became the reason for the diversity of funeral traditions of its inhabitants. The ancient cemetery, full of burials, was formed over a millennium, and it is of enormous size. The best preservation of the archaeological landscape of the necropolis in the region is noted. The burial mounds are complex architectural structures. Most of the stone tombs underneath are badly destroyed. In addition to stone, mud brick was used to build tombs under the kurgans, but most tombs were cut into the ground. The most complex technique is used when excavating ground crypts. They had a complex design and enormous dimensions. Wood is rarely preserved in deep burials of Phanagoria, but modern methods of field work make it possible to reconstruct wooden structures based on the imprints of objects in the ground. The necropolis of Phanagoria is a reference site for the study of ancient cemeteries on the territory of the Taman Peninsula.

Keywords

Phanagoria, necropolis, antiquity, burials, field archaeology, research methodology, Taman Peninsula.

Aleksey N. Voroshilov, Institute of Archaeology of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Olga M. Voroshilova, Institute of Archaeology of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Kuznetsov, V.D., 2007: Fanagoriya: istoriya issledovaniy i novye nakhodki. [Phanagoria: the history of research and recent findings]. Rossiyskaya arkheologiya [Russian Archaeology], 2, 5–15.

Kuznetsov, V.D., 2015: Syrtsovyy kirpich (po materialam Fanagorii) [Raw brick (based on the materials of the Phanagoria)]. Problemy istorii, filologii, kul’tury [Journal of Historical, Philological and Cultural Studies], 1, 282–294.

Zavoykin, A.A., Kolesnikov, A.B., Sudarev, N.I., 2016: Pozdnearkhaicheskie pogrebeniya na «Yuzhnom gorode» Fanagorii [Late Archaic burials in the “Southern City” of Phanagoria]. In: V.D. Kuznetsov (ed.), Materialy po arkheologii i istorii Fanagorii [Materials on Archaeology and History of Phanagoria] 2. (Fanagoriya [Phanagoria], 4). Moscow, 110– 207.

Zavoykin, A.A., Shavyrina, T.G. 2013: Pogrebenie 23/1980 Vostochnogo nekropolya Fanagorii: k voprosu o zakuporke antichnykh amfor [Burial on 23/1980 of the Eastern necropolis of Phanagoria: on the issue of occlusion of ancient amphorae]. In: V.D. Kuznetsov (ed.), Fanagoriya. Rezul`taty arkheologicheskikh issledovaniy [Phanagoria. Results of Archaeological Research] 1 (Fanagoriya [Phanagoria]), 1). Modcow, 230–239.

download PDF

Abstract

The article presents the results of a comprehensive study of a metal mirror with plot images originating from the Eastern Trans-Kuban region. A flat mirror with a trapezoidal handle belongs to type IV, according to the classification of I.I. Marchenko, and, according to external signs, dates back to the end of the 2nd–1st centuries AD. Mirrors of this type are characteristic for the material culture of the Meotians of the North-Western Caucasus. X-ray fluorescence analysis of the metal showed that the mirror was made of tin-lead bronze with a high content of tin (>18%) and a moderate content of lead (~5%). This technology reflects the Meoto-Sarmatian metallurgical traditions characteristic of the region. The images engraved on the mirror represent a composition of three scenes: the “tree of life” with ungulates standing on both sides (central scene), a duel between two horsemen (upper scene), and a wolf hunting for fallow deer (lower scene). The style of the image and the plots presented in the composition have analogies in the monuments of applied art of the Sarmatians and Meotians. The plot scenes engraved on the mirror reflect the religious, mythological or epic ideas of the ancient population of the North- Western Caucasus.

Keywords

Mirror, North-Western Caucasus, X-ray fluorescence analysis, tin-lead bronze, Meotians, Sarmatians, plot images, mythology, religion, epos.

Andrey M. Novichikhin, Anapa Archaeological Museum, Anapa, Russia, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Tatiana N. Smekalova, V.I. Vernadsky Crimean Federal University, Simferopol, Russia, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Aleksandr G. Kokoulin, Independent researcher, Yevpatoria, Russia, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Alekseev, A.Yu. 2003: Greben’ iz kurgana Solokha i skifskie tsari V–IV vekov do n.e. [Comb from the Solokha Kurgan and Scythian kings of the 5th–4th centuries BC]. Arkheologicheskiy sbornik Gosudarstvennogo Ermitazha [Archaeological collection of the State Hermitage] 56, 72–88.

Anfimov, N.V. 1951: Meoto-sarmatskiy mogil’nik u stanitsy Ust’-Labinskoy [Meoto-Sarmatian burial ground near the village of Ust-Labinskaya]. In: Materialy i issledovaniya po arkheologii Severnogo Kavkaza [Materials and research on the archeology of the North Caucasus] (Materialy i issledovaniya po arkheologii SSSR [Materials and Research on the Archaeology of the USSR] 23), 155–207.

Anfimov, N.V. 1992: Meotskiy sosud s mifologicheskimi stsenami [Meotian vessel with mythological scenes]. In: G.Kh. Mekulov (ed.), Voprosy arkheologii Adygei [Questions of Archaeology of Adygea]. Maykop, 287–293.

Bartseva, T.B. 1981: Tsvetnaya metalloobrabotka skifskogo vremeni (Lesostepnoe dneprovskoe levoberezh’e) [Non-ferrous metalworking of the Scythian time (Forest-steppe Dnieper left bank)]. Moscow.

Berlizov, N.E., Pyankov, A.V., Smaglyuk, M.I. 2019: Bronzovoe zerkalo s gravirovannymi izobrazheniyami iz novykh postupleniy v Krasnodarskiy muzey-zapovednik [Bronze mirror with engraved images from new acquisitions in the Krasnodar Museum-Reserve]. Iz istorii kul’tury narodov Severnogo Kavkaza [From the history of culture of the peoples of the North Caucasus] 11, 162–176.

Beylin, D.V., Rukavishnikova, I.V., Fedoseev, N.F., Smekalova, T.N., Antipenko, A.V., Loboda, A.Yu., Guryeva, P.V., Kovalenko, E.S., Murashev, M.M., Tereshchenko, E.Yu., Yatsishina, E.B. 2024: Kamennyy sklep na severnom uchastke nekropolya Pantikapeya (rayon «Glinishche»): kompleksnyy analiz metallicheskikh nakhodok [Stone crypt in the northern section of the Panticapaeum necropolis (Glinishche area): a comprehensive analysis of metal finds]. Rossiyskaya arkheologiya [Russian Archaeology] 1, in print.

Bogdanova-Berezovskaya, I.V. 1975: K voprosu o khimicheskom sostave zerkal Minusinskoy kotloviny [On the question of the chemical composition of the mirrors of the Minusinsk Basin]. In: Lubo-Lesnichenko, E.I. Privoznye zerkala Minusinskoy kotloviny [Imported mirrors from the Minusinsk basin]. Moscow, 131–141.

Craddok, P.T. 1978: The composition of the Copper Alloys used by the Greek, Etruscan and Roman civilisations: 3. The origins and Early use of Brass. Journal of Archaeological Science 5, 1–16.

Dungworth, D.B. 1995: Iron Age and Roman copper alloys from northern Britain. Durham theses, Durham University. Available at: http://etheses.dur.ac.uk/1024/

Dvornichenko, V.V., Fedorov-Davydov, G.A. 1981: Falary iz sarmatskogo pogrebeniya mogil’nika Krivaya Luka IX v Astrakhanskoy oblasti [Falars from a Sarmatian burial at the Krivaya Luka IX burial ground in the Astrakhan region]. Kratkie soobshcheniya Instituta arkheologii [Brief Communications of the Institute of Archaeology] 168, 100–105.

Erlikh, V.R. 2014: Drevnosti doliny yablon’. Katalog vystavki [Antiquities of the valley of apple trees. Exhibition catalogue]. Moscow.

Erlikh, V.R. 2015: Ot remesla – k iskusstvu. Putevoditel’ po arkheologicheskoy ekspozitsii SKF GMV [From craft to art. Guide to the archaeological exposition of the North Caucasian branch of the State Museum of Oriental Art]. Moscow.

Ermolenko, L.N. 2010: O smysle «levogo» i «pravogo» v kompozitsii nekotorykh pamyatnikov izobrazitel’nogo iskusstva drevnosti [On the meaning of “left” and “right” in the composition of some monuments of the fine arts of antiquity]. Ural’skiy istoricheskiy vestnik [Ural Historical Bulletin] 1, 53–61.

Guguev, V.K. 1992: [Kobyakovsky barrow (On the issue of eastern influences on the culture of the Sarmatians in the 1st century AD – early 2nd century AD)]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 4, 116–129.

Gulyaev, V.I. 2016: Antropomorfnye poyasnye pryazhki skifskogo vremeni iz Kryma [Anthropomorphic belt buckles of the Scythian period from the Crimea]. Kratkie soobshcheniya Instituta arkheologii [Brief Communications of the Institute of Archaeology] 245 (1), 185–190.

Khazanov, A.M. 1963: Genezis sarmatskikh bronzovykh zerkal [Genesis of Sarmatian bronze mirrors]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya [Soviet Archaeology] 4, 58–71.

Khazanov, A.M. 1964: Religiozno-magicheskoe ponimanie zerkal u sarmatov [Religious and magical understanding of mirrors among the Sarmatians]. Sovetskaya etnografiya [Soviet Ethnography] 3, 89–96.

Kisel, V.A. 1993: Stilisticheskaya i tekhnologicheskaya atributsiya serebryanogo zerkala iz Kelermesa [Stylistic and technological attribution of the silver mirror from Kelermes]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 1, 111–125.

Kisel, V.A. 2003: Shedevry yuvelirov Drevnego Vostoka iz skifskikh kurganov [Masterpieces of jewelers of the Ancient East from the Scythian burial mounds]. Sankt Petersburg.

Limberis, N.Yu., Marchenko, I.I. 2023: O nekotorykh kategoriyakh meotskogo importa v rannesarmatskikh pogrebeniyakh [On some categories of Meotian imports in early Sarmatian burials]. In: Regional’nye osobennosti arkheologicheskoy periodizatsii savromatskoy i sarmatskikh kul’tur. Materialy XI Vserossiyskoy nauchnoy konferentsii s mezhdunarodnym uchastiem “Problemy sarmatskoy arkheologii i istorii”, posvyashchennoy pamyati A.S. Skripkina [Regional features of the archaeological periodization of the Sauromatian and Sarmatian cultures. Materials of the 11th All-Russian scientific conference with international participation “Problems of Sarmatian archeology and history”, dedicated to the memory of A.S. Skripkin]. Volgograd, 114–127.

Limberis, N.Yu., Marchenko, I.I., Kondratenko, A.V. 2020: Pogrebeniya meotskikh vsadnikov s boevymi toporami iz Prikubanskogo mogil’nika [Burials of Meotian horsemen with battle axes from the Kuban burial ground]. Arkheologicheskoe nasledie [Archaeological Heritage] 3, 152–167.

Lysenko, A.V., Masyakin, V.V., Mordvintseva, V.I. 2015: Mogila № 1 nekropolya rimskogo vremeni Luchistoe-2 (Yuzhnyy Krym) [Grave No. 1 of the necropolis of the Roman period Luchistoye-2 (South Crimea)]. Istoriya i arkheologiya Kryma [History and Archaeology of Crimea] 2, 295–333, 620–628.

Maksimova, M.I. 1954: Serebryanoe zerkalo iz Kelermesa [Silver mirror from Kelermes]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya [Soviet Archaeology] XXI, 281–305.

Marchenko, I.I. 1996: Siraki Kubani (po materialam kurgannykh pogrebeniy Nizhney Kubani) [Siraki of the Kuban (Based on the burial mounds of the Lower Kuban)]. Krasnodar.

Meeks, N.D. 1986: Tin-rich surfaces on bronze – some experimental and archaeological considerations. Archaeometry 28 (2), 133–162.

Mizhaev, M.I. 2002: Kosmogonicheskie mify adygov [Cosmogonic myths of the Adygs]. In: R.A. Khanakhu (ed.), Mir kul’tury adygov (problemy evolyutsii i tselostnosti) [The world of culture of the Adyghes (problems of evolution and integrity)]. Maykop, 62–79.

Moshkova, M.G., Ryndina, N.V 1975: Sarmatskie zerkala Povolzh’ya i Priural’ya (khimikotekhnologicheskoe issledovanie) [Sarmatian mirrors of the Volga and Ural regions (chemical and technological research)]. In: B.A. Kolchin (ed.), Ocherki tekhnologii drevneyshikh proizvodstv [Essays on the technology of ancient industries]. Moscow, 117–133.

Narty… 1974: Narty. Adygskiy geroicheskiy epos [The Narts. Adyghe heroic epic]. Moscow.

Novichikhin, A.M., Smekalova, T.N. 2021: Kompleks predmetov konskogo snaryazheniya protomeotskogo vremeni i ranneskifskoe zerkalo s yuzhnogo berega Krasnodarskogo vodokhranilishcha. Mezhdistsiplinarnoe issledovanie [A complex of items of horse equipment of the Proto-Meotian period and an early Scythian mirror from the southern shore of the Krasnodar reservoir. Interdisciplinary research]. In: A.A. Malyshev, A.Yu. Skakov (eds.), Kobanskaya kul’turno-istoricheskaya obshchnost’ v kontekste drevnostey Kavkaza. Pamyati doktora istoricheskikh nauk V.I. Kozenkovoy [Koban cultural and historical community in the context of the antiquities of the Caucasus. In memory of Doctor of Historical Sciences V.I. Kozenkova]. Moscow, 178–197.

Olkhovskiy, V.S. 2021: Rel’ef s poseleniya Yubileynoe I: etnograficheskie i fol’klornye realii [A Relief from the Settlement Yubileinoye I: Ethnographie and Folklore Features]. In: E. Savostina (ed.), Bosporskiy rel’ef so stsenoy srazheniya (Amazonomakhiya?) [Bosporan battle relief (Amazonomachia?)]. Moscow–Sankt Petersburg, 144–181.

Pristupa, O.I., Starodumov, D.O., Yakovlev, Ya.A. Okno v beskonechnost’. Bronzovye zerkala rannego zheleznogo veka [Window to infinity. Bronze mirrors of the early Iron Age]. Khanty-Mansiysk.

Prokhorova, T., Guguev, V. 1988: Bogatoe sarmatskoe pogrebenie v kurgane na vostochnoy okraine g. Rostova-na-Donu [A rich Sarmatian burial in a burial mound on the eastern outskirts of Rostov-on-Don]. Izvestiya Rostovskogo oblastnogo muzeya kraevedeniya [Proceedings of the Rostov Regional Museum of Local Lore] 5, 40–49.

Prokhorova, T.A. 1994: Nekotorye aspekty ideologii sarmato-alan [Some aspects of the ideology of the Sarmatian-Alans]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 4. 174–182.

Prokhorova, T.A., Guguev, V.K. 1992. Bogatoe sarmatskoe pogrebenie v kurgane 10 Kobyakovskogo mogil’nika [A rich Sarmatian burial in Kurgan 10 of the Kobyakovsky burial ground]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya [Soviet Archaeology] 1, 142–161.

Pugachenkova, G.A. 1987: Iz khudozhestvennoy sokrovishchnitsy Srednego Vostoka [From the Artistic Treasury of the Middle East]. Tashkent, 56–64.

Ravich, I.G. 1983: Etalony mikrostruktur olovyannoy bronzy [Standards of microstructures of tin bronze]. Khudozhestvennoe nasledie. Khranenie, issledovanie, restavratsiya [Artistic heritage. Storage, research, restoration] 8, 136–142.

Ravich, I.G. 2001: Nekotorye tipy vysokoolovyannykh goryachekovanykh zerkal sarmatskogo vremeni i ikh tekhnologicheskie osobennosti [Some types of high-tin hot-forged mirrors of the Sarmatian period and their technological features]. Istoriko-arkheologicheskiy al’manakh [Historical and Archaeological Almanac] 7, 43–54.

Ravich, I.G. 2004. K voprosu o proiskhozhdenii i primenenii zerkal sarmatskogo vremeni s valikom po krayu diska. [On the question of the origin and use of mirrors of the Sarmatian period with a roller along the edge of the disk]. Issledovaniye i konservatsiya pamyatnikov kul’tury [Research and conservation of cultural monuments]. Moscow, 67–76.

Ravich, I.G. 2006: Nekotorye tipy vysokoolovyannykh goryachekovannykh zerkal sarmatskogo vremeni i ikh tekhnologicheskie osobennosti [Some types of hot-forged mirrors of Sarmatian times with high tin content (technical specifics)]. Kratkie soobshcheniya Instituta arkheologii [Brief Communications of the Institute of Archaeology] 220, 42–51.

Ravich, I.G. 2007: Tekhniko-tekhnologicheskaya kharakteristika izdeliy iz tsvetnogo metalla iz Raevskogo nekropolya [Technical and technological characteristics of non-ferrous metal products from the Raevsky necropolis.]. In: A.A. Malyshev (ed.), Yugo-Vostochnaya periferiya Bospora v ellinisticheskoe vremya. Po materialam Raevskogo nekropolya [Southeastern periphery of the Bosporus in the Hellenistic period. Based on the materials of the Raevsky necropolis]. Moscow, 234–242.

Ravich, I.G. 2008: Khimiko-tekhnologicheskaya kharakteristika izdeliy iz tsvetnogo metalla iz pogrebeniy nekropoley v Tsemmesskoy doline i Shirokoy Balke (I–III vv. n.e.) [Chemical- technological characteristics of non-ferrous metal items from necropolis burials in the Tsemmes Valley and Shirokaya Balka (1st–3rd centuries AD)]. In: A.A. Malyshev (ed.), Aspurgiane na yugo-vostoke Aziatskogo Bospora. Po materialam Tsemdolinskogo mogil’nika [Aspurgians in the southeast of the Asian Bosporus. According to the materials of the Tsemdolinsky burial ground]. Moscow, 272–279.

Ravich, I.G. 2011: Osobennosti sostava izdeliy iz tsvetnogo metalla, naydennykh v nekropole Shirokaya Balka [Features of the composition of non-ferrous metal items found in the Shirokaya Balka necropolis]. In: A.A. Malyshev (ed.), Naselenie predgoriy severo-zapadnogo Kavkaza v rimskuyu epokhu po materialam nekropolya v Shirokoy Balke [The population of the foothills of the northwestern Caucasus in the Roman era based on materials from the necropolis in Shirokaya Balka]. Moscow, 369–374.

Rostovtsev, M.I. 1913: Antichnaya dekorativnaya zhivopis’ na Yuge Rossii. Atlas [Antique decorative painting in the South of Russia. Atlas]. Sankt Petersburg.

Rostovtsev, M.I. 1914: Antichnaya dekorativnaya zhivopis’ na Yuge Rossii. Tekst [Antique decorative painting in the South of Russia. Text]. Sankt Petersburg.

Savelyeva, A.S. 2019: Ob elementnom sostave metalla zerkal tagarskoy kul’tury [On the elemental composition of the metal of mirrors of the Tagar culture.]. Uchenye zapiski muzeyazapovednika «Tomskaya Pisanitsa» [Scientific Notes of the Museum-Reserve “Tomskaya Pisanitsa”] 9, 40–52.

Shemakhanskaya, M.S. 2008: Fenomen vysokoolovyanistoy posudy – ot drevnosti do nashikh dney [The phenomenon of high-tin utensils – from antiquity to the present day]. In: A.V. Trezvov, L.I. Lifshits, O.V. Yakhont (eds.), Issledovaniya v konservatsii kul’turnogo naslediya. Vyp. 2. Materialy mezhdunarodnoy nauchno-metodicheskoy konferentsii, posvyashchennoy 50-letnemu yubileyu GosNIIR [Studies in the conservation of cultural heritage. Vol. 2. Materials of the international scientific and methodological conference dedicated to the 50th anniversary of State Research Institute of Restoration]. Moscow, 291–298.

Sokol’skiy, N.I. 1976: Tamanskiy tolos i rezidentsiya Khrisaliska [Taman tholos and residence of Chrysaliscus]. Moscow.

Sorokina, N.P., Treyster, M.Yu. 1983: Dve gruppy bronzovykh zerkal iz sobraniya Gosudarstvennogo istoricheskogo muzeya [Two groups of bronze mirrors from the collection of the State Historical Museum]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya [Soviet Archaeology] 4, 142–153.

Tigeeva, E.V., Belonogova, L.N. 2018: Zerkala sargatskoy kul’tury Tobolo-Ishimskogo mezhdurech’ya [Mirrors of the Sargatka culture in the Tobol-Ishim interfluve basin]. Vestnik arkheologii, antropologii i etnografii [Journal of Archaeology, Anthropology and Ethno graphy] 4 (43), 84–96.

Treyster, M.Yu. 1994: Sarmatskaya shkola khudozhestvennoy torevtiki (K otkrytiyu serviza iz Kosiki) [Sarmatian Toreutic School (A Tableware Set from Koika)]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 1, 172–203.

von Hall, X. 1997: Stsena poedinka vsadnikov na serebryanoy vaze iz Kosiki (Istoki i vospriyatie odnogo iranskogo motiva v Yuzhnoy Rossii) [A Duel of Horseman on the Silver Vase from Kosika (Sources and Perception of an Iranian Motif in Southern Russia)]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 2, 174–198.

Yatsenko, S.А. 1986: Diademy stepnykh kochevnikov Vostochnoy Evropy v sarmatskuyu epokhu [Tiaras of the steppe nomads of Eastern Europe in the Sarmatian era]. Kratkie soobshcheniya Instituta arkheologii [Brief Communications of the Institute of Archaeology] 186, 14–20.

Yatsenko, S.А. 2000a: Atropomorfnye obrazy v iskusstve iranoyazychnykh narodov Sarmatii II–I vv. do n.e. [The Antropomorphical Images in the Art of the Iranian-speaking Peoples of Sarmatia in the II–I cc. BC]. Stratum plus 4, 251–272.

Yatsenko, S.А. 2000b: Epicheskiy syuzhet iranoyazychnykh kochevnikov v drevnostyakh stepnoy Evrazii [An Epic Subject of the Iranian-Speaking Nomads in the Antiquities of the Eurasian Steppes]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 4, 86–104.

Zasetskaya, I.P. 1975: Zolotye ukrasheniya gunnskoy epokhi. Po materialom Osoboy kladovoy Gosudarstvennogo Ermitazha [Golden jewelry of the Hun era. Based on material from the Special Storeroom of the State Hermitage]. Leningrad.

Zasetskaya, I.P. 2008: Zolotye ukrasheniya iz kurgana Khokhlach – klassicheskie obraztsa sarmatskogo polikhromnogo zverinogo stilya I – nachala II v. n.e. [Gold jewelry from the Khokhlach mound is a classic example of the Sarmatian polychrome animal style of the 1st – early 2nd centuries AD]. In: Sokrovishcha sarmatov: Katalog vystavki. K 100-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya akademika B.B. Piotrovskogo [Treasures of the Sarmatians: Exhibition catalogue. To the 100th anniversary of Academician B.B. Piotrovsky]. Sankt Petersburg– Azov, 30–43.

download PDF

Abstract

The paper discusses the finds of red- and gray clay pottery and molded lamps at the Polyanka settlement. The first are few (8 whole pieces). Most of the latter (13 specimens) most likely served as incense burners. Almost all of the pottery and up to half of the stucco come from the premises and date back to the 1st century BC. All of them find numerous analogies in various ancient sites of the Bosporus and the Northern Black Sea region. Pottery and partly molded incense burner lamps, along with some other artifacts and archaeological evidence, are a kind of indicator of the residential purpose of a particular room.

Keywords

Russian Science Foundation, project No. 23-18-00088.

Aleksandr A. Maslennikov

Institute of Archaeology of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia;

V.I. Vernadsky Crimean Federal University, Simferopol, Russia

E-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Arsenyeva, T.M. 1988: Svetil’niki Tanaisa [Lamps of Tanais]. Moscow.

Chistov, D.S. 2023: Pomeshcheniya-oykosy v antichnoy zhiloy arkhitekture Severnogo Prichernomor’ya. In: Bosporskiy fenomen: quarta pars saeculi. Itogi, problemy, diskussii. Materialy mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoy konferentsii. Sankt Petersburg, 100–109.

Chrzanovski, L. Zhuravlev, D. 1998: Lamps from Chersonesos in the State Historical Museum – Moscow (Studia Archaeologica 94). Roma.

Maslennikov, A.A. 2007: Sel’skie svyatilishcha Evropeyskogo Bospora [Rural sanctuaries of the European Bosporus]. Moscow.

Maslennikov, A.A. 2019. Seroglinyanaya keramika s lakovym pokrytiem iz raskopok poseleniya Polyanka v Vostochnom Krymu [Dark-glossed gray clay pottery from the Polyanka settlement in the Eastern Crimea]. RA 4, 134–143.

Puzdrovskiy, A.E. 2007: Krymskaya Skifiya II v. do n.e. – III v. n.e. Pogrebal’nye pamyatniki [Crimean Scythia in the 2nd century BC – 3rd century AD. Funerary monuments]. Simferopol.

Sinika, V.S., Melnikova, V.A., Telnov, N.I. 2014: Lepnye kuril’nitsy iz pamyatnikov Severnogo Prichernomor’ya VI–I vv. do n.e. [Molded incense burners of the 6th to 1st centuries BC from the sites of the Northern Black Sea region]. Stratum plus 3, 65–101.

Zhuravlev, D.V. 2010: O bosporskikh svetil’nikakh tipa «kuvshinchika» [About Bosporan jugshaped lamps]. Problemy istorii, filologii, kul’tury [Journal of Historical, Philological and Cultural Studies] 1, 264–276.

Zhuravlev, D.V., Bykovskaya, N.V. 2023: Importnye svetil’niki s volyutami iz sobraniya Vostochno-Krymskogo istoriko-kul’turnogo muzeya-zapovednika [Imported lamps with volutes in the East Crimean Historical and Cultural Museum-Reserve]. In: A.V. Makhlayuk (ed.), Professor E.A. Molev i sovremennye problemy antikovedeniya. Materialy nauchnoy konferentsii «Istoriko-arkheologicheskiy simpozium pamyati professora Evgeniya Aleksandrovicha Moleva», Institut mezhdunarodnykh otnosheniy i mirovoy istorii NNGU im. N.I. Lobachevskogo, Nizhniy Novgorod, 22 yanvarya 2022 g. [Professor E.A. Molev and modern problems of ancient studies. Proceedings of the Scientific Conference “Historical and Archaeological Symposium in Memory of Professor Evgeniy Aleksandrovich Molev”, Institute of International Relations and World History of Nizhny Novgorod State University. N.I. Lobachevsky, Nizhny Novgorod, January 22, 2022]. Nizhniy Novgorod, 48–78.

Zhuravlev, D.V., Bykovskaya, N.V., Zheltikova, A.L. 2010: Svetil’niki vtoroy poloviny III v. do n.e. – IV v. n.e.: importnye ellinisticheskie svetil’niki. Bosporskie svetil’niki ellinisticheskogo i rimskogo vremeni [Lamps of the Second Half of the 3rd Century BC – 4th century AD: imported Hellenistic lamps. Bosporan lamps from Hellenistic and Roman times] (Iz sobraniya Kerchenskogo istoriko-kul’turnogo zapovednika. Kollektsiya svetil’nikov [From the collection of the Kerch Historical and Cultural Reserve. Collection of lamps]. Vol. II). Kiev.

Zhuravlev, D.V., Lomtadze, G.A. 2022: Stolovaya posuda i svetil’niki iz Rezidentsii Khrisaliska [Tableware and lamps from the Chrysaliskos Residence]. Drevnosti Bospora [Antiquities of the Bosporus] 27, 59–100.

download PDF

Abstract

The article deals with to the problem of determining the issuing authorities of the socalled “Sindi” coinage. Many scholars consider it to be coinage of the Sindi tribe. These include S.A. Kovalenko, who suggests in his article that the reason for minting coins is the desire of the Sindi kings to make a profit from striking. At the same time, in his opinion, electrum coins of some Asia Minor mints (Cyzicus, Phocaea) were used as metal for it, from which silver was obtained. This point of view is refuted by chemical analyzes of the composition of metals in the “Sindi” coin. Moreover, it confl icts with some important facts. First of all, it should be noted that the coin was minted in Sindike, which belonged to the Greek cities that were located in this territory. The inscription of Theopropides from Nymphaeum definitely confirms this. A very important point is that among the so-called “Sindi” coins there is a type of griffin sitting in front of a grain that is directly related to Phanagoria. This fact alone refutes the opinion of the coin as belonging to the Sindi. To this it should also be added that the Sindi coinage was of a completely Greek nature. The combination of various facts indicates that in the 5th century BC on the Asian side of the Cimmerian Bosporus there was a union of the Greek poleis of Sindike. It was this union that minted coins at the time of Panticapaean aggression against them to finance military actions.

Keywords

Sindike, Sindi, coinage.

Vladimir D. Kuznetsov

Institute of Archaeology of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia;

State Historical and Archaeological Museum-Reserve “Phanagoria”

E-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Abramov, A.P. 2010: Patrei [Patraeus]. In.: G.M. Bongard–Levin, V.D. Kuznetsov (eds.), Antichnoe nasledie Kubani I [Ancient Heritage of Kuban I]. Moscow, 529–539.

Abramzon, M.G., Saprykina, I.A., Chugaev, A.V., Presnyakova, N.N., Tereshchenko, E.Yu. 2021: Elementnyi sostav i svintsovo-izotopnye kharakteristiki metalla serebryanykh monet Bospora i Ionii V–I vv. do n.e. [Chemical and Pb-Isotopic Characteristics of Metal of Silver Coins of the Bosporus and Ionia Dated from the 5th to 1st centuries BC]. Rossiyskie nanotekhnologii [Nanobiotechnology Reports] 16/5, 644–650.

Abramzon, M.G., Zavoykin, A.A., Kuznetsov, V.D., Saprykina, I.A. 2020: Bosporskiye serebryanye monety klassicheskogo vremeni iz Fanagorii [Bosporan Silver Coins of the Classical Period from Phanagoria]. Hypanis 2, 5–26.

Antonaccio, C.M. 2001: Ethnicity and Colonization. In: I. Malkin (ed.), Ancient Perceptions of Greek Ethnicity (Center for Hellenic Studies Colloquia 5). Cambridge (Mass.)–London, 113–157.

Avram, A. 2022: Sur un possible koinon des cités du Pont Gauche à l’époque hellénistique. In: G. Tsetskhladze (ed.), Ionians in the West and East (Colloquia Antiqua 27). Leuven–Paris– Bristol, 765–771.

Balcer, J.M. 1968: The Early Silver Coinage of Teos. Schweizerische Numismatische Rundschau XLVII, 5–50.

Beck, H. 1997: Polis und Koinon. Untersuchungen zur Geschichte und Struktur der griechischen Bundesstaaten im 4. Jahrhundert v. Chr. (Historia Einzelschriften 114). Stuttgart.

Beck, H., Funke P. (eds.). 2015: Federalism in Greek Antiquity. Cambridge.

Beck, H., Funke, P. 2015: An Introduction to Federalism in Greek Antiquity. In: H. Beck, P. Funke (eds.), Federalism in Greek Antiquity. Cambridge, 1–19.

Beck, H., Ganter, A. 2015: Boiotia and the Boiotian Leagues. In: H. Beck, P. Funke (eds.), Federalism in Greek Antiquity. Cambridge, 132–157.

Beck, H., Buraselis, K., McAuley, A. (eds.) 2019: Ethnos and Koinon. Studies in Ancient Greek Ethnicity and Federalism. Stuttgart.

Bissa, E.M.A. 2009: Governmental Intervention in Foreign Trade in Archaic and Classical Greece. Leiden–Boston.

Braund, D. 2007: The Sindians of the Taman Peninsula ca. 400 BC: Polyaenus’ Tirgatao, Numismatics and Demosthenes’ Grandfather. In: S.L. Solovyev (ed.), Greeks and Natives in the Cimmerian Bosporos 7th – 1th Centuries BC (BAR Int. Series 1729). Oxford, 17–21.

Carrocio, B. 2011: Parallel Striking Reconstruction and Chronological Numismatic Interpretation. In: F. de Callataÿ (ed.), Quantifying Monetary Supplies in Greco-Roman Times. Bari, 81– 103.

Chryssanthaki-Nagle, K. 2007: L’histoire monétaire d’Abdère (VIe s. avant J.-C. – IIe s. après J.-C.). Athènes.

Coleman, J.E., Walz, C.A. (eds.) 1997: Greeks and Barbarians. Essays on the Interactions between Greeks and Non-Greeks in Antiquity and the Consequences for Eurocentrism. Bethesda.

Dana, M. 2011: Culture et mobilité dans le Pont Euxin. Approche régionale de la vie culturelle des cités grecques (Ausonius. Scripta Antiqua 37). Bordeaux.

Dreher, M. 2003: Symmachia und Sympoliteia in der Griechischen Welt bis 323 v. Chr. In: K. Buraselis, K. Zoumboulakis (eds.), The Idea of European Community in History. Vol. II. Aspects of Connecting Poleis and Ethne in Ancient Greece. Athens, 26–50.

Dubuisson, M. 1982: Remarques sur le vocabulaire grec d’acculturation. Revue belge de philologie et d’histoire LX, 5–32.

Fronda, M.H. 2015: The Italiote League and Southern Italy. In: H. Beck, P. Funke (eds.), Federalism in Greek Antiquity. Cambridge, 386–402.

Funke, P., Haake, M. (eds.). 2013: Greek Federal States and Their Sanctuaries. Stuttgart.

Garlan, Y. 1989: Guerre et économie en Grèce ancienne. Paris.

Giovannini, A. 2007: Les relations entre États dans la Grèce antique du temps d’Homère à l’intervention romaine (ca. 700‒200 av. J.‒C.) (Historia Einzelschriften 193). Stuttgart.

Gorman, V.B. 2001: Miletos, the Ornament of Ionia. A History of the City to 400 B.C.E. Ann Arbor.

Goroncharovskiy, V.A., Ivantchik, A.I. 2010: Sindy [Sindoi]. In: G.M. Bongard-Levin, V.D. Kuznetsov (eds.), Antichnoe nasledie Kubani I [Ancient Heritage of Kuban I]. Moscow, 218–234.

Goroncharovskiy, V.A., Tereshchenko, A.E. 2014: Tipologiya i khronologiya sindskoi chekanki [Typology and Chronology of Sindian Mint]. In: Bospor Kimmeriyskiy i varvarskiy mir v period antichnosti i srednevekovya. Aktualnye problemy i khronologiya [The Cimmerian Bosporus and Barbarian World in the Ancient and Medieval Periods. Current Issues and Chronology] (XV Bosporskiye chteniya [Bosporan Readings].). Kerch, 99–114.

Grielaard, J.P. 2009: The Ionians in the Archaic Period. Shifting Identities in a Changing World. In: T. Derks, N. Roymans (eds.), Ethnic Constructs in Antiquity. The Role of Power and Tradition. Amsterdam, 37–79.

Griffith, G.T. 1935: The Mercenaries of the Hellenistic World. Cambridge.

Hall, J.M. 1997: Ethnic Identity in Greek Antiquity. Cambridge.

Hall, J.M. 2002: Hellenicity. Chicago–London.

Hall, J.M. 2015: Federalism and Ethnicity. In: H. Beck, P. Funke (eds.), Federalism in Greek Antiquity. Cambridge, 30–48.

Harrison, Th. (ed.). 2002: Greeks and Barbarians. Edinburgh.

Horden, P., Purcell, N. 2000: The Corrupting Sea. A Study of Mediterranean History. Oxford.

Ivantchik, A. 2012: Agoranomes dans les cités du Pont nord et occidentales. In: L. Capdetrey, Cl. Hasenohr (éds.), Agoranomes et édiles. Institutions des marchés antique (Ausonius. Scripta Antiqua 44). Bordeaux, 121–130.

Konuk, K. 2012: Asia Minor to the Ionian Revolt. In: W.E. Metcalf (ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Greek and Roman Coinage. Oxford, 43–60.

Kovalenko, S.A. 2020: Monety sindov: nekotorye zamechanya o prichinakh, kharaktere i khronologii chekanki [Coins of Sindoi: Some Notes on the Causes, Nature and Chronology of the Coinage]. In: A.V. Belousov, E.V. Ilyushechkina (eds.), Homo Omnium Horarum. Sbornik statey v chest 70-letiya A.V. Podosinova [Homo Omnium Horarum. Collection of Articles in Honor of the 70th Anniversary of A.V. Podossinov]. Moscow, 272–296.

Kraay, C.M. 1976: Archaic and Classical Greek Coins. Berkeley–Los Angeles.

Krasilnikoff , J.A. 1992: Aegean Mercenaries in the Fourth to Second Centuries BC: A Study in Payment, Plunder and Logistics of Ancient Greek Armies. Classica et Mediaevalia 43, 23–36.

Krasilnikoff , J.A. 1993: The Regular Payment of Aegean Mercenaries in the Classical Period. Classica et Mediaevalia 44, 77–95.

Kuznetsov, V.D. 2000: Organizatsiya obschestvennogo stroitelstva v drevnei Gretsii [Organization of Public Construction in Ancient Greece]. Moscow.

Kuznetsov, V.D. 2016: Fanagoriya i Sindika: nekotorye zametki [Phanagoria and Sindike: Some Remarks]. In: A.A. Zavoykin (ed.), Materialy po arkheologii i istorii Fanagorii [Materials on Archaeology and History of Phanagoria] 2 (Fanagoriya [Phanagoria] 4). Moscow, 250– 278.

Kuznetsov, V.D. 2018: Bospor Kimmeriyskiy v 5 v. do n.e. (drevnepersidskaya nadpis iz Fanagorii) [Cimmerian Bosporus in the Fifth Century BC (Ancient Persian Inscription from Phanagoria]. In: V.D. Kuznetsov, A.A. Zavoykin (eds.), Materialy po arkheologii i istorii Fanagorii 3 [Materials on Archaeology and History of Phanagoria (Fanagoriya [Phanagoria] 6). Moscow, 250–278.

Kuznetsov, V.D., Abramzon, M.G. 2020: Klad pozdnearchaicheskikh monet iz Fanagorii [A Hoard of Late Arckhaic coins from Phanagoria] (Fanagoriya [Phanagoria] 8). Moscow

Kuznetsov, V.D., Abramzon, M.G. 2021: The Beginning of Coinage in the Cimmerian Bosporus (A Hoard from Phanagoria) (Colloquia Antiqua 34). Leuven–Paris–Bristol.

Larsen, J.A.O. 1968: Greek Federal States. Their Institutions and History. Oxford.

Launey, M. 1949–1950: Recherches sur les armées hellénistiques. 2 vols. Paris.

Lohmann, H. 2012: Ionians and Carians in the Mykale: the Discovery of Carian Melia and the Archaic Panionion. In: G. Cifani, S. Stoddart (eds.), Lanscape, Ethinicity and Identity in the Archaic Mediterranean Area. Oxford–Oakville, 32–50.

Loomis, W.T. 1998: Wages, Welfare Costs and Infl ation in Classical Athens. Ann Arbor.

Luce, J.-M. (éd.) 2007: Identités ethniques dans le monde grec antique (Pallas 73). Toulouse.

Mackil, E. 2013: Creating a Common Polity. Religion, Economy, and Politics in the Making of the Greek Koinon. Berkeley‒Los Angeles‒London.

Mackil, E. 2015: The Economics of Federation in the Ancient Greek World. In: H. Beck, P. Funke (eds.), Federalism in Greek Antiquity. Cambridge, 487–502.

Mackil, E., van Alfen, P.G. 2006: Cooperative Coinage. In: P.G. van Alfen (ed.), Agoranomia: Studies in Money and Exchange Presented to J.H. Kroll. New York, 201–246.

Mac Sweeney, N. 2013: Foundation Myths and Politics in Ancient Ionia. Cambridge.

Malkin, I. (ed.). 2001: Ancient Perceptions of Greek Ethnicity (Center for Hellenic Studies Colloquia 5). Cambridge (Mass.)–London.

Marinovich, L.P. 1975: Grecheskoe naemnichestvo IV v. do n.e. i krizis polisa. Moscow

Marinovich L.P. 1988. Le Mercenariat grec au IVe siècle avant notre ère et la crise de la polis. Paris.

May, J.M.F. 1966: The Coinage of Abdera (540–345 BC). London.

Mitchell, L. 2007: Panhellenism and the Barbarian. Swansea.

Mitchell, L. 2015: The Community of the Hellenes. In: H. Beck, P. Funke (eds.), Federalism in Greek Antiquity. Cambridge, 49–65.

Müller, Ch. 2010: D’Olbia à Tanaïs. Territoires et réseaux d’échanges dans la mer Noire septentrionale aux époques classique et hellénistique. Bordeaux.

Parke, H.W. 1933: Greek Mercenary Soldiers from the Earliest Times to the Battle of Ipsus. Oxford.

Porucznik, J. 2021: Cultural Identity within the Northern Black Sea Region in Antiquity. (De) constructing Past Identity (Colloquia Antiqua 31). Leuven–Paris–Bristol.

Pritchett, W.K. 1971: The Greek State at War. Pt. 1. Berkeley–Los Angeles–London.

Psoma, S., Tsangari, D. 2003: Monnaie commune et états fédéraux. La circulation des monnayages frappés par les états fédéraux du monde grec. In: K. Buraselis, K. Zoumboulakis (eds.), The Idea of European Community in History. Vol. II. Aspects of Connecting Poleis and Ethne in Ancient Greece. Athens, 111–141.

Raaflaub, K.A. 2015: Forerunners of Federal States: Collaboration and Integration Through Alliance in Archaic and Classical Greece. In: H. Beck, P. Funke (eds.), Federalism in Greek Antiquity. Cambridge, 434–451.

Rizakis, A. 2015: The Achaian League. In: H. Beck, P. Funke (eds.), Federalism in Greek Antiquity. Cambridge, 118–131.

Rzepka, J. 2002: Ethnos, Koinon, Sympoliteia, and Greek Federal States. In: T. Derda, J. Urbanik, M. Węcowski eds.), ΕΥΕΡΓΕΣΙΑΣ ΧΑΡΙΝ. Studies Presented to B. Bravo and E. Wipszycka. Warsaw, 225–247.

Saprykin, S.Yu. 2006: Etyudy po sotsialnoi i ekonomicheskoi istorii Bosporskogo tsarstva [Essays on the Social and Economic History of the Bosporan Kingdom]. In: Antichnaya tsivilizatsiya i varvary [Ancient Civilization and Barbarians]. Moscow, 171–242.

Smarczyk, B. 2015: The Hellenic Leagues of Late Classical and Hellenistic Times and Their Place in the History of Greek Federalism. In: H. Beck, P. Funke (eds.), Federalism in Greek Antiquity. Cambridge, 452–470.

Smekalova, T.N. 2000: Znachenie izucheniya sostava monetnykh splavov dlya antichnoy numizmatiki (na primere Bospora) [Importance of Studying the Composition of Coin Alloys for Ancient Numismatics]. Bosporskie drevnosti [Antiquities of the Bosporus] 3, 260–301.

Smekalova, T.N., Dyukov, Yu.A. 2007: Monetnye splavy gosudarstv Prichernomoriya. Bospor, Olviya, Tira [Coin Alloys of the North Pontic States. Bosporus, Olbia, Tyras]. Saint Petersburg.

Sokolova, O.Yu., Pavlichenko, N.A. 2002: Novaya posvyatitelnaya nadpis iz Nimfeya [New Dedication from Nymphaion]. Hyperboreus 8, 99–121.

Spier, J. 1990: Emblems in Archaic Greece. Bulletin of the Institute of Classical Studies 37, 107–129.

Strokin, V.L. 2012: Sindskiye monety: vzglyad iz Sindiki [Sindian Coins: A View from Sindike]. Bosporskie drevnosti [Antiquities of the Bosporus] 16, 379–417.

Tokhtasyev, S.R. 2001: Esche raz o sindskikh monetakh i sindskom tsarstve [Once Again About Sindian Coins and Sindian Kingdom]. In: Bosporskiy fenomen: kolonizatsiya regiona, formirovaniye polisov, obrazovaniye gosudarstva [Bosporos Phenomenon: Colonization of the Region, Poleis and States Formation]. P. I. Saint Petersburg.

Trubachev, O.N. 1999: Indoarica v Severnom Prichernomoriye [Indoarica in the Northern Pontus]. Moscow.

Trundle, M. 2004: Greek Mercenaries. From the Late Archaic Period to Alexander. London– New York.

Yatsenko, V.V., Titelakis, A.V. 2005: O neizvestnom variante sindskikh gemitetartemoriev [About an Unknown Variant of the Sindian Hemitetartemorion]. In: Trinadtsataya Vserossiyskaya numizmaticheskaya konferentsiya (Tezisy dokladov i soobscheniy) [13th All-Russian Numismatic Conference (Abstracts and Papers)]. Moscow, 28–29.

van Alfen, P. 2012: Problems in the Political Economy of the Archaic Greek Coinage. Notae Numismaticae VII, 13–36.

Vlassopoulos, K. 2013: Greeks and Barbarians. Cambridge.

Wartenberg, U. 2020: Was There an Ionian Revolt Coinage? Monetary Patterns in the Late Archaic Period. In: P. van Alfen, U. Wartenberg (eds.), White Gold. Studies in Early Electrum Coinage. New York–Jerusalem, 569–640.

Zavoykin, A.A. 1998: Sindskaya Gavan (Sindik) – Gorgippia [Sindian Harbour (Sindik) – Gorgippia]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 3, 134–145.

Zavoykin, A.A. 2004a: “Dve Sindiki” (zametki kasaemo istoricheskoi znachimosti posvyascheniya Teopropida, syna Megakla, iz Nimfeya [“Two Sindikes” (Notes on the Historical Significance of the Dedication of Theopropides, Son of Megakles, from Nymphaion]. Drevnosti Bospora [Antiquities of the Bosporus] 7, 150–161.

Zavoykin, A.A. 2004b: Fanagoriya vo vtoroi polovine V – nachale IV v. do n.e. (po materialam raskopok “Yuzhnogo goroda” [Phanagoria in the Second Half of the Fifth – Beginning of the Fourth Centuries BC (After Results of Excavations at the “South City” Trench (Drevnosti Bospora [Antiquities of the Bosporus]. Suppl. I. Moscow.

Zavoykin, A.A. 2013: Obrazovaniye Bosporskogo gosudarstva. Archeologiya i khronologiya stanovleniya derzhavy Spartokidov [Formation of Bosporan State. Archaeology and Chronology of the Formation of the State]. (Bosporskie issledovaniya [Bosporos Studies] 10) Simferopol–Kerch.

Zograf, A.N. 1951: Antichnye monety [Ancient Coins]. Moscow–Leningrad.

download PDF

Abstract

This is a publication of a unique bronze jug from the cache of the burial a young woman in a burial mound excavated in 1989 near the Krasny Kut Farmstead on the left bank of the Manych River, dating from the second half of the 2nd – early 3rd century AD. The jug has already been described and discussed several times in the 1990s, so in this article I shall limit myself to the main conclusions and also present new parallels and considerations. The images on both the handle and the body of the jug are associated with the Trojan cycle, a description of the events that took place during the siege of Troy, the death of Achilles and the story of the sacrifice of Polyxena by Neoptolemus at the tomb of his father. If we accept the dating of the jug in question, substantiated here, to the 2nd century AD, and even more to the period of the Marcomannic Wars, it is obvious that there was not a big gap between the time of manufacture of the jug and its deposition in the burial, although there is no need to talk about the connection between the context of the find and the symbolism of the jug – it was hidden in the the cache of the burial of a young Sarmatian woman, probably not its first owner, and the routes along which it penetrated to the nomads in the vicinity of Tanais could have been diff erent, including that via the Cimmerian Bosporus. Compared to other Roman bronze vessels from Sarmatia, the jug in question certainly stands out. It was a piece of high-quality workmanship. It is no coincidence that a jug similar in shape and decorative technique, supposedly found in the Tiber, is considered to be a gift of Emperor.

Keywords

Lower Don area, Sarmatia, Roman imports, bronze jug, scenes of the Trojan cycle, Achilles, Neoptolemos, Polyxena, iconography.

Mikhail Yu. Treister

Independent Researcher, Bonn, Germany

E-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Adriani, A. 1960: Il vaso argenteo di Ingolstadt e un suo modello alessandrino. RM 67, 111–125.

Armand-Caillat, L. 1959: Patères en bronze trouvées près de Lyon à l‘Ile-Barbe. RA 2, 65–76.

Babelon, E. 1916: Le trésor de Berthouville près Bernay (Eure) conservé au département des médailles et antiquités de la Bibliothèque Nationale. Paris.

Bennett, J. 2005: Trajan Optimus Princeps. A Life and Times. London–New York.

Baratte, F. 1984a: A propos d‘une coupe en argent trouvee en Gaule. Revue du Nord 56, 221–230.

Baratte, F. 1984b: Römisches Silbergeschirr in den gallischen und germanischen Provinzen (Kleine Schriften Limesmuseum Aalen 32). Stuttgart.

Baratte, F. 1997a: Silbergeschirr in Gallien und den benachbarten Provinzen. In: Kat. Bonn 1997, 59–70.

Baratte, F. 1997b: Silbergeschirr, Kultur und Luxus in der römischen Gesellschaft (15. Trierer Winckelmannsprogramm 1997). Mainz.

Baratte, F. 2001: Orient et Occident: le témoignage d’une trouvaille d’argenterie d’époque parthe en Asie centrale. Journal des savants, 249–307.

Barbanera, M. 2014: Dressing to Hunt. Some Remarks on the Calyx Krater from the So-Called House of C. Julius Polybius in Pompei. In: A. Avramidou, D. Demetriou (eds.), Approaching the Ancient Artifact: Representation, Narrative, and Function, Berlin–Boston, 91–104.

Bérard, Cl. 1967: Art alexandrin et mystères dionysiaques. Le vase bachique d‘Avenches. ProAventico 19, 57–90.

Bielefeld, R. 2005: Orestes auf römischen Sarkophagen. Berlin.

Boucher, S., Tassinari, S. 1976: Musée de la Civilisation Gallo-Romaine à Lyon. Bronzes Antiques. Т. I. Paris.

Brailsford, J.W. 1964: Guide to the Antiquities of Roman Britain. 3rd ed. London.

Braun, C. 1988: Römische Bronzegefäße mit Reliefdekor. In: K. Gschwantler, A. Bernhard- Walcher (Hrsg.), Griechische und römische Statuetten und Grossbronzen. Akten der 9. Internationalen Tagung über antike Bronzen (Wien, 21.–25. Aprii 1986). Wien, 331–333.

Braun, C. 2001: Römische Bronzebalsamarien mit Reliefdekor (BAR Intern. Ser. 917). Oxford.

Carus, P. 1900: The History of the Devil and the Idea of Devil. Chicago.

Cat. Belgrade 1969 – Popovic, Lj. B., Mano-Zisi, D., Velickovic, M., Jelicic, B. Anticka bronza u Jugoslaviji. Beograd, 1969

Cat. Cambridge, Mass. 1968 – D.G. Mitten, S.F. Doeringer (eds.), Master Bronzes from the Classical World. Cambridge, Mass, 1968

Cat. Leningrad 1973 – Antichnaya khudozhestvennaya bronza: Katalog vystavki v Ermitazhe [Antique Artistic Bronze: Catalogue of the Exhibition in the Hermitage]. Leningrad, 1973

Кат. Ленинград 1973 – Античная художественная бронза: Каталог выставки в Эрмитаже. Л., 1973

Cat. Los Angeles 2014 – K. Lapatin (ed.), The Berthouville Silver Treasure and Roman Luxury. Los Angeles, 2014

Cat. Milan 1997 – Rifl essi di Roma. Imperio Romano e barbari del Baltico. Roma, 1997

Cat. Paris 1989 – F. Baratte, K. Painter (eds.), Trésors d’orfèvrerie gallo-romains. Paris, 1989

Cohon, R., Benson, P., Meyers, P., Stone, R. 2004: A Case of mistaken Millennia: A wounded Barbarian in Kansas City. Antike Kunst 47, 55–64.

Corfù, N.A. 2016: Der Polyxena-Sarkophag von Çanakkale – archaisch oder archaistisch? Numismatica e Antichità Classiche, Quaderni Ticinesi 45, 43–66.

Christies New York. Antiquities, 11 December 2014. Sale BES-3403.

Curtius, L. 1934: Orest und Iphigenie in Tauris. Zum Bronzekrater von Dionysopolis-Balcik. RM 49, 246–294.

D’Andria, F. 1979: Vasi di bronzo romani di recente scoperti in Puglia e Lucania. In: Bronzes hellénistiques et romains. Tradition et renouveau. Actes du Ve Colloque international sur les bronzes antiques, Lausanne, 8–13 mai 1978 (Cahiers d’archéologie romande 17). Lausanne, 223–228.

Draycott, C.M. 2018: Making Meaning of Myth. On the Interpretation of Mythological Imagery in the Polyxena Sarcophagus and the Kızılbel Tomb and the History of Achaemenid Asia Minor. In: L. Audley-Miller, B. Dignas (eds.), Wandering Myths. Transcultural Uses of Myth in the Ancient World. Berlin–Boston, 23–70.

Eremin, K. 2014: Analytical Approaches to Ancient Bronzes. In: S. Ebbinghaus (ed.), Ancient Bronzes through as Modern Lense. Introductory Essays on the Study of Ancient Mediterranean and Near Eastern Bronzes. Cambridge, 65–92.

Esposito, A. 2019: Performing the Sacra: Priestly Roles and their Organisation in Roman Britain (Archaeopress Roman Archaeology 53). Oxford.

Faust, S. 2012: Schlachtenbilder der römischen Kaiserzeit: erzählerische Darstellungskonzepte in der Reliefkunst von Traian bis Septimius Severus (Tübinger Archäologische Forschungen 8). Rahden.

Ferris, I. 2021: Visions of the Roman North. Art and Identity in Northern Roman Britain ( Archaeopress Roman Archaeology 80). Oxford.

Friesen, C.J.P. 2016: Dying like a Woman: Euripides’ Polyxena as Exemplum between Philo and Clement of Alexandria. Greek, Roman, and Byzantine Studies 56, 623–645.

Froning, H. 1980: Die ikonographische Tradition der kaiserzeitlichen Sarkophagreliefs. JdI 95, 322–341.

Furtwängler, A. 1896: Beschreibung der Geschnittenen Steine im Antiquarium. Berlin.

Furtwängler, A. 1900: Die antiken Gemmen: Geschichte der Steinschneidekunst im Klassischen Altertum 1–3. Leipzig–Berlin.

Gabelmann, H. 1984: Antike Audienz- und Tribunalszenen. Darmstadt.

Geischer, H.-J. 1967: Heidnische Parallelen zum frühchristlichen Bild des Isaak-Opfers. Jahrbuch für Antike und Christentum 10, 127–144.

Gesztelyi, T. 2005: Jünglingsgestalten mit Waff e auf pannonischen Gemmen. In: Akten des VIII. Internationalen Kolloquiums über Probleme des provinzialrömischen Kunstschaff ens. Zagreb, 305–310.

Gesztelyi, T. 2007: Virum fortém plerumque Achillem vocamus. In: I. Tar, P. Mayer (Hrsg.), Klassizismus und Modernität. Beiträge der internationalen Konferenz in Szeged (11–13. September 2003) (Acta Antiqua et Archaeologica XXX). Szeged, 224–231.

Giumlia-Mair, A., Mrav, Z. 2014: The aes corinthium Vessels from Egyed, Hungary. Folia archaeologica 56, 73–102.

Goulyaeva, N. 2000: The Collection of Roman Bronzes in the Hermitage Museum. Kölner Jahrbuch 33, 161–172.

Grane, T. 2007: The Roman Empire and Southern Scandinavia – a Northern Connection. A Reevaluation of Military-political Relations Between the Roman Empire and the Barbaricum in the First Three Centuries AD with a Special Emphasis on Southern Scandinavia. PhD dissertation, University of Copenhagen. Copenhagen.

Guguev, V.K. 2013: O pryamoy analogii stsene zhertvoprinosheniya na kuvshine iz kurgana u s. Krasnyy Kut [On the direct Analogy to the Scene of Sacrifition on the Jug from the Burial Mound near the village of Krasnyy Kut]. In: V.Yu. Zuev (ed.), Bosporskiy fenomen. Greki i varvary na Evraziyskom perekrestke. Materialy mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoy konferentsii (Sankt-Peterburg, 19–22 noyabrya 2013 g.) [Bosporan Phenomenon. The Greeks and the Barbarians on the Eurasian Crossroad. The Materials of the International Scientific Conference (Saint Petersburg, 19–22 November 2013)]. Saint Petersburg, 461–469.

Гугуев, В.К. 2013: О прямой аналогии сцене жертвоприношения на кувшине из кургана у с. Красный Кут. В сб.: В.Ю. Зуев (ред.), Боспорский феномен. Греки и варвары на Евразийском перекрёстке. Материалы международной научной конференции (Санкт-Петербург, 19–22 ноября 2013 г.). СПб., 461–469.

Guguev, V.K., Treister, M. Ju. 1992 : Une oenochoé de bronze a scènes mythologiques provenant d’un kourgane sarmate de la région de Rostov. RA 2, 243–271.

Hengel, M. 1982: Achilleus in Jerusalem. Sitzungsbericht der Heidelberger Akademie der Wissenschaften, Philosophisch-historische Klasse, Jg. 1982. Bericht 1. Heidelberg.

Henig, M. 1984: Religion in Roman Britain. London.

Himmelmann, N. 1989: Herrscher und Athlet. Die Bronzen vom Quirinal. Bonn.

Hobbs, R., Jackson, R. 2010: Roman Britain Life at the Edge of Empire. London.

Jackson, R. 1990: Waters and Spas in the Classical World. Medical History Suppl. 10, 1–13.

Junge, M. 1983: Untersuchungen zur Ikonographie der Erinys in der griechischen Kunst. Kiel.

Kapeller, A. 2003: La vaisselle en bronze d’Avenches / Aventicum. ProAventico 45, 83–147.

Kat. Berlin 2011 – Grüßinger, R., Kästner, V., Scholl, A. Pergamon. Panorama der antiken Metropole. Begleitbuch zur Ausstellung. Berlin, 2011

Kat. Bonn 1997 – Prittwitz und Gaff ron, H.-H. von, Mielsch, H. (Hrsg.), Das Haus lacht vor Silber. Köln–Bonn, 1997

Kat. Köln 1988 – Harden, D.B. Glas der Caesaren. Milano, 1988

Kat. Mannheim 2004 – Guzzo, P.G., Wieczorek, A. (Hrsg.), Pompeji. Die Stunden des Untergangs. 24. August 79 n. Chr. Darmstadt, 2004

Kirova, N. 2006: Römische Skalpelle mit Silbereinlagen aus den Provinzen Moesia Inferior und Thrakia. Archäologische Korrespondenzblatt 36.4, 537–548.

Konova. L. 2006: „Iphigenie auf Tauris“ an der Schwarzmeerküste. Probleme des kulturellen Synkretismus in den Westpontischen Poleis. In: S. Conrad, R. Einicke, A.E. Furtwängler, H. Löhr, A. Slawisch (Hrsg.), Pontos Euxeinos. Beiträge zur Archäologie und Geschichte des antiken Schwarzmeer- und Balkanraumes (ZAKS Schriften 10). Langenweißbach, 81– 92.

Krämer, W. 1967: Der Fundort des sogenannten Ingolstädter Silberbechers im Münchner Antiquarium. BayVgBl 32, 23–28.

Künzl, E. 1984: Das Gebet des Chryses (Homer, Ilias, 1. Gesang): Griechisches Epos und römische Politik auf der vergoldeten Silberkanne des Octavius Menodorus. JbRGZM 31, 365–384.

Künzl, E., Künzl, S. 1984: Aquae Apollinares/Vicarello (Italien). In: R. Chevallier 1992 (ed.), Les eaux thermales et les cultes des eaux en Gaule et dans les provinces voisines. Actes du colloque 28–30 septembre 1990 Aix-les-Bains (Caesarodunum 26). Tours–Turin, 273–296.

Künzl, S. 1993: Das Tafelgeschirr (D2–121). In: E. Künzl (Hrsg.), Die Alamannenbeute aus dem Rhein bei Neupotz (Plünderungsgut aus dem römischen Gallien) (Monographien des RGZM 34, 1). Mainz, 113–227.

Lamb, W. 1929: Ancient Greek and Roman Bronzes. London.

Lehmann-Hartleben, K. 1938: Two Roman Silver Jugs. AJA 42, 82–105.

Leibundgut, A. 1976: Die römischen Bronzen der Schweiz. Bd. II. Avenches. Mainz.

Marčenko, I.I., Limberis, N.J. 2008: Römische Importe in sarmatischen und maiotischen Denkmälern des Kubangebietes. In: A. Simonenko, I.I. Marčenko, N.J. Limberis, Römische Importe in sarmatischen und maiotischen Gräbern (Archäologie in Eurasien. 25). Mainz, 267–400.

Mielsch, H. 1997: Römisches Tafelsilber aus Ägypten. In: Kat. Bonn 1997, 41–58.

Muscarella, O.W. 1988: Bronze and Iron. Ancient Near Eastern Artifacts in the Metropolitan Museum of Arts. New York.

Nenova-Merdjanova, R. 2011: Production and Consumption of Bronzework in Roman Thrace. In: I.P. Haynes (ed.), Early Roman Thrace: New Evidence from Bulgaria (Journal of Roman Archaeology Supplementary Series 82). Portsmouth, 115–134.

Noll, R. 1988: Kostbare Tintenfässer. BayVgBl 53, 83–97.

Nuber, H.-U. 1972: Kanne und Griff schale. BerRGK 53, 1–232.

Painter, K. 2001: The Insula of the Menander at Pompeii. IV. The Silver Treasure. Oxford.

Parise Presicce, C. 1993. Cratere a calice con scena mitologica. In: Riscoperte Pompei. Exhibition catalogue. Rome, 222–224.

Pfrommer, M. 1982: Grossgriechischer und mittelitalischer Einfl uss in der Rankenornamentik frühhellenistischer Zeit. JdI 97, 119–190.

Pfrommer, M. 1985: Ein Bronzebecken in Malibu. The J. Paul Getty Museum Journal 13, 9–18.

Pfrommer, M. 1987: Studien zu alexandrinischer und grossgriechicher Toreutik frühhellenistischer Zeit (Archäologische Forschungen 16). Berlin.

Picard, C. 1962–1963: Aigle et serpent: sur les divers sens d’un symbole religieux á travers la Grèce du Nord: d’après un oenochoé de bronze du Musée de Belgrade. Starinar N.S. XIII– XIV (1965), 1–7.

Popović, I. 1994: Античко сребро у Србиjи / Antique Silver from Serbia. Beograd.

Ratković, D. 2005: Bronzane posude: iz rimske zbirke Narodnog Muzeja u Beogradu /Roman Bronze Vessels in the Roman Collection of the National Museum in Belgrade (Антика / Antiquity IX). Beograd.

Reinsberg, C. 2022: Der spätarchaische Polyxenasarkophag. Antike Plastik 32. Wiesbaden, 1–143.

de Ridder, A. 1915: Les bronzes antiques du Louvre. T. II. Les instruments. Paris.

Robert, C. 1890: Die antiken Sarkophagreliefs. Bd. II. Berlin.

Robert, C. 1919: Archaeologische Hermeneutik. Anleitung zur Deutung klassischer Bildwerke. Berlin.

Rolley, C. 1986: Greek Bronzes. Fribourg.

Rolley, C. 2002: Le travail du bronze à Delphes. BCH 126.1, 41–54.

Schäfer, T. 1989: Die Dakerkriege Trajans auf einer Bronzekanne (eine Auftragsarbeit für den Praetorianerpraefekt Ti. Claudius Livianus). JdI 104, 283–317.

Schindler, W. 1980: Allegorie der Iulia Augusti als Iphigenie auf dem Bronze-Krater in Varna. Klio 62.1, 99–109.

Schindler, W. 1985: Der Iphigenie-Krater in Varna – ein Restitutionsstück. Thracia 7, 123–134.

Schwarz, G. 1992: Achill und Polyxena in der römischen Kaiserzeit. RM 99, 265–299.

Schwarz, G. 2001: Der Tod und das Mädchen. Frühe Polyxena-Bilder. AM 116, 35–50.

Sevinç, N. 1996: A New Sarcophagus of Polyxena from the Salvage Excavations at Gümüşçay. Studia Troica 6, 251–264.

Shkorpil, K. 1932: Arkheologicheski belezhki ot Chernomorskoto kraybrezhie [Archaeological Notes from the Black Sea Coast]. Izvestiya na b‘lgarskiya arkheologicheski institut [Bulletin of the Bulgarian Archaeological Institute 6 (1932), 57–88.

Шкорпил, К. 1932: Археологически бележки от Черноморското крайбрежие. Известия на българския археологически институт 6 (1932), 57–88.

Simon, E. 1986: Augustus. Kunst und Leben in Rom um die Zeitenwende. München.

Sinn, U. 2011: Einführung in die klassische Archäologie. München.

Stefanelli, L.P.B. 1990: Il bronzo dei Romani. Roma.

Stefanelli, L.P.B. 1991: L’argento dei Romani. Roma.

Strocka, V.M. 2015: Der Manchinger Silberbecher. Eine Fehldeutung und ihre Folgen. BJb 215, 323–352.

Strong, D.E. 1966: Greek and Roman Gold and Silver Plate. London.

Tassinari, S. 1993: Il vasellame bronzeo di Pompei. Roma.

Treister, M. 1994: A New Example of Ancient Metalwork from a Sarmatian Kurgan. Expedition 36.2–3, 38–46.

Treister, M.Yu. 1997: Bronzovyy kuvshin so stsenami troyanskogo tsikla iz sarmatskogo kurgana na r. Manych [A bronze Jug with the Scenes of the Trojan Cycle from the Sarmatian Burial Mound on the Manych River]. In: L.I. Akimova (ed.), Vvedenie v khram [Entering the Temple]. Moscow, 204–212.

Трейстер, М.Ю. 1997: Бронзовый кувшин со сценами троянского цикла из сарматского кургана на р. Маныч. В кн.: Л.И. Акимова (ред.). Введение в храм. М., 204–212.

Treister, М.Yu. 2007: Tekhnika i elementy dekora. Chekannye i gravirovannye ornament [The Technique and Elements of Decoration. Chased and Incised Pattern]. In: Mordvintseva, V.I., Treister, М.Yu. Proizvedeniya torevtiki i yuvelirnogo iskusstva v Severnom Prichernomor’e. II v. do n.e. – II v. n.e. [The Items of Toreutics and Jewellery Art in the North Pontic Area. 2nd Century BC – 2nd Century AD]. Vol. 1. Simferopol, Bonn, 245–255.

Трейстер, М.Ю. 2007: Техника и элементы декора. Чеканные и гравированные орнаменты. В кн.: Мордвинцева, В.И., Трейстер, М.Ю. Произведения торевтики и ювелирного искусства в Северном Причерноморье. II в. до н.э. – II в. н.э. Т. 1. Симферополь–Бонн, 245–255.

Treister, М.Yu. 2019: O dvukh rimskikh bronzovykh kuvshinakh iz sarmatskikh pogrebeniy Podon’ya [On the Two Roman Bronze Jugs from the Sarmatian Burials of the Don Region]. Stratum plus (4), 113–132.

Трейстер, М.Ю. 2019: О двух римских бронзовых кувшинах из сарматских погребе- ний Подонья. Stratum plus (4), 113–132.

Treister, М.Yu. 2020a: Busy i elementy dekora iz yantarya v yuvelirnykh izdeliyakh iz pogrebeniy kochevnikov Aziatskoy Sarmatii v kontekste torgovli ekzoticheskimi materialami v Evrazii [Beads and Elements of Decoration made of Amber in the Items of Jewellery from the Burials of the Nomads of Asian Sarmatia in the Context of the Trade of Exotic Materials in Eurasia]. Materialy po arkheologii i istorii antichnogo i srednevekovogo Prichernomor‘ya [Materials on Archaeology and History of the Ancient and Medieval Black Sea Region] 12, 148–223.

Трейстер, М.Ю. 2020а: Бусы и элементы декора из янтаря в ювелирных изделиях из погребений кочевников Азиатской Сарматии в контексте торговли экзотическими материалами в Евразии. МАИАСП 12, 148–223.

Treister, М.Yu. 2020b: Rimskie bronzovye sosudy s medal‘onami s figurnymi izobrazheniyami iz Sarmatii [Roman Bronze Vessels with Medallions with Figural Scenes from Sarmatia]. In: А.V. Belousov, Е.V. Ilyushechkina (eds.), Homo omnium horarum: Sbornik statey v chest‘ 70-letiya A.V. Podosinova [Homo omnium horarum: Collection of Articles in Honor of the 70th anniversary of A.V. Podosinov]. Мoscow, 565–610.

Трейстер, М.Ю. 2020б: Римские бронзовые сосуды с медальонами с фигурными изображениями из Сарматии. В сб.: А.В. Белоусов, Е.В. Илюшечкина (ред.), Homo omnium horarum: Сборник статей в честь 70-летия А.В. Подосинова. М., 565–610.

Treister, М.Yu. 2023: Bronzovye tsedilki tipa Eggers 160 iz pogrebeniy kochevnikov Aziatskoy Sarmatii [Bronze Strainers of the Eggers 160 Type from the Burials of the Nomads of Asian Sarmatia]. Kratkie soobshcheniya Instituta arkheologii [Brief Reports of the Institute of Archaeology] 270, 40–52.

Трейстер, М.Ю. 2023: Бронзовые цедилки типа Eggers 160 из погребений кочевников Азиатской Сарматии. КСИА 270, 40–52.

Walters, H.B. 1921: Catalogue of the Silver Plate (Greek, Etruscan and Roman) in the British Museum. London.

Wünsche, R. 1991: Pasquino. Münchner Jahrbuch 42, 7–38.

Zazoff , P. 1983: Die antiken Gemmen (Handbuch der Archäologie). München.