I.Yu. Vashcheva (Nizhny Novgorod) – Eusebius of Caesarea’s “Church History”: Terminology and Problems of Ethno-Cultural Identity on the Threshold of the Middle Ages
Abstract
The article deals with one of the very complicated and controversial problematic of transitivity – the problem of the formation of a new identity of society under the passing from Antiquity to the Middle Ages. The époque of Late Antiquity (the 4th – 7th centuries) having become a subject of special research comparatively not very long ago, gives a stunning pattern of replacement of social-cultural paradigm, when the deep transformation of all the social foundations, changing of mental structures, particularly, the crisis of traditional ethnocultural identity and a forming of a new one were taking place. In this article, an attempt of analysis of mechanisms of these global changes is made. Package treatment of ethnic, political, religious and cultural aspects of identity gives to the article interdisciplinary character. The author shows how was the habitual principle of human separation in the Hellenes and the Romans on the one hand and ‘barbarians’ on the other hand, replaced in Eusebius’ work by a new principle depending on confession. Whereby the mechanisms of such mental transformation were rather soft without the need for drastic break with the tradition. The author points the two ones. First, it was a rethinking of traditional categories when their meaning moved from the ethno-geographic sphere to political one. One more mechanism was emphasis transfer from ethnic to ethical and moral characteristics. For the Christian author the main criteria for distinguishing some people of others became now a moral characteristics, existence some moral virtues in one or another people, mode of life and behaviors. As a result, the fi rst church historian, not breaking any traditional beliefs and perceptions, came to quite new interpretation of identity of that society. Therefore, thinking in the frames of previous paradigm, the fi rst church historian carried out a revolutionary change in oekumene perception, changing not only certain assessments of some people but also a principle itself for humanity division. In the context of the crisis of the roman identity when traditional ideals and values of Roman society became a thing of the past irreversibly, the fi rst Christian historian Eusebius of Caesarea validates a new form of identity which is religious. Among the all peoples of the oekumene he distinguishes the Christian one, enduing it with all that values and merits that new society will identify itself with.
Ващева, И.Ю. 2002: Этнокультурные и конфессиональные группы в мировоззрении пер- вого христианского историка. В сб.: А.В. Махлаюк (ред.), Aкра. Сборник научных трудов. Нижний Новгород, 34–44.
Ващева, И.Ю. 2004: Механизмы формирования исторического сознания на рубеже III–IV веков (по данным «Церковной истории» Евсевия Кесарийского). В сб.: Е.В. Молев (ред.), Медиевистика и социальная работа. Нижний Новгород, 21–49.
Ващева, И.Ю. 2005: Античные категории в мировосприятии первого церковного историка. В кн.: Древнее Средиземноморье: религия, общество, культура. М., 230–254.
Ващева, И.Ю. 2006: Евсевий Кесарийский и становление раннесредневекового историзма. СПБ.
Ващева, И.Ю. 2012: Кризис римской идентичности в IV–VII вв. Вопросы истории 10, 110–117.
Гиббон, Э. 1997: История упадка и разрушения Римской империи. Ч. II. М.
Григорюк, Т.В. 2011: «Римский народ» в IV в.н.э. В сб.: В.В. Дементьева (ред.), Народ и демократия в древности. Доклады российско-германской научной конференции. Ярославль, 287–292.
Каждан, А. П. 1965: От Христа к Константину. М.
Корелин, М.С. 1901: Падение античного миросозерцания (культурный кризис в Римской империи). СПб.
Кривушин, И.В. 1996: Евсевий Кесарийский, отец церковной истории. В кн.: И.В. Кри- вушин, Н.В. Ревякина (ред.), Интеллектуальная история в лицах: Семь портретов мыслителей Средневековья и Возрождения. Иваново, 7–24.
Кривушин, И.В. 1998: Ранневизантийская церковная историография. СПБ.
Кривушин, И.В.1995: Рождение церковной историографии: Евсевий Кесарийский. Ива- ново.
Крывелев, И. А. 1985: Библия: историко-критический анализ. М.
Лебедев, А.П. 2000: Церковная историография в главных ее представителях с IV до XX вв. СПБ.
Удальцова, З.В. 1984: Развитие исторической мысли. В кн.: Культура Византии. IV – пер- вая половина VII века. М., 182–191.
Шукуров Р.М. 2008: Конфессия, этничность и византийская идентичность. [Электрон- ный ресурс]. Режим доступа: http://www.centre-fr.net/spip.php?article169&lang=ru.
Ahrweiler, H. 1975: L’idéologie politique de l’empire byzantin. Paris.
Barnes, T. D. 1981: Constantine and Eusebius. Cambridge.
Cameron, A., Cameron, A. 1964: Christianity and Tradition in the Historiography of the Late Empire. The Classical Quarterly (New Series) 14/2, 316–328.
Cameron, A. 1971: Agathius. Oxford.
Cameron, A. 1985: Procopius and the Sixth Century. London.
Cameron, A. 2010: The Byzantines. Wiley–Blackwell.
Cameron, A. 2014: Byzantine matters. Princeton.
Chesnut, G. 1977: The First Christian Histories: Eusebius, Socrates, Sozomen, Theodoret and Evagrius. Paris.
Chrysos, E. 1996: The Roman Political Identity in Late Antiquity and Early Byzantium in Byzantium. In: K. Fledelius (ed.), Identity, Image, Infl uence. XIX International Congress of Byzantine Studies. University of Copenhagen, 18–24 August, 1996. Major Papers. Copenhagen, 7–16.
Colish, M.L.1985: The Stoic tradition from Antiquity to the Early Middle Ages. Brill.
Comparetti, D. 1997: Vergil in the Middle Ages. Princeton.
Dagron, G. 1964: Aux origines de la civilisation byzantine: langue de culture et langue d’état. Revue historique 241, 23–56.
Digeser, E. 2006: Christian or Hellene? The great persecution and the problem of identity. In: R.M. Frakes, E. Digeser (eds.), Religious Identity in Late antiquity. Toronto.
Digeser, E., Frakes, R.M., Stephens, J. 2010: The Rhetoric of Power in Late Antiquity: Religion and Politics in Byzantium, Europe and the Early Islamic World. London–New York.
Fouracre, P. (еd.) 2005: The New Cambridge Medieval History: c. 500 – c. 700. Cambridge.
Geary, P.J. 1983: Ethnic Identity as a Situational Construct in the Early Middle Ages. Mitteilungen der anthropologischen Gesellschaft in Wien 113, 15–26.
Grant, R.M. 1980: Eusebius as Church Historian. Oxford.
Iricinschi, Ed., Zellentin, H.M. (eds.) 2008: Heresy and Identity in Late Antiquity. Texts and Studies in Ancient Judaism 119. Tubingen.
Kaldellis, A. 2004: Procopius of Caesarea: Tyranny, History and Philosophy at the End of Antiquity. Philadelphia.
Kaldellis, A.E. 2007: Hellenism in Byzantium: the transformations of Greek Identity and the Reception of the Classical Tradition (Greek Culture in the Roman World). Cambridge–New York.
Kaldellis, A.E. 2012: From Rome to New Rom, from Empire to Nation-State: Reopening the Question of Byzantium’s Roman Identity. In: L. Grig, G. Kelly (eds.), Two Romes. Rome and Constantinople in Late Antiquity. Oxford–New York, 387–404.
Koder, J. 1996: Byzantinische Identität– einleitende Bemerkungen in Byzantium. In: K. Fledelius (ed.), Identity, Image, Infl uence. XIX International Congress of Byzantine Studies. University of Copenhagen, 18–24 August, 1996. Major Papers. Copenhagen, 3–6.
Koder, J. 2012: Sprache als Identitätsmerkmal bei den Byzantinern. Auf -isti endende sprachbezogene Adverbien in den griechischen Quellen. Anzeiger der Philosophischhistorischen Klasse. 147/2, 5–37.
Laurence, R., Berry, J. (eds.) 1998: Cultural Identity in the Roman Empire. London.
Nguyen, V.H.T. 2008: Christian Identity in Corinth: A Comparative Study of 2 Corinthians, Epictetus and Valerius Maximus (Wissenschaftlishe Untersuhungen zum Neuen Testament. 2/243). Tübingen.
Overbeck, F. 1892: Uber die Anlange der Kirchengeschichtssc hreibung. Basel. Page Gill 2008: Being Byzantine: Greek Identity before the Ottomans. Cambridge. [Электрон- ный ресурс]. Режим доступа: http://scholarworks.iu.edu/journals/index.php/tmr/article/ view/ 16788/22906.
Pohl, W., Heydemann, G. (eds.) 2013: Strategies of Identifi cation: Ethnicity and Religion in Early Medieval Europe. Turnhout.
Rapp, C. 2008. Hellenic Identity, Romanitas and Christianity in Byzantium. In: K. Zacharia (ed.), Hellenismus. Culture, Identity, and Ethnicity from Antiquity to Modernity. Aldershot, 127–147.
Schwartz, E. 1957: Griechische Geschichtsschreiber. Leipzig.
Smythe, D.C. 1996: Byzantine Identity and Labelling Theory. In: In: K. Fledelius (ed.), Identity, Image, Infl uence. XIX International Congress of Byzantine Studies. University of Copenhagen, 18–24 August 1996. Major Papers. Copenhagen, 26–36.
Stouraitis, I. 2014: Roman Identity in Byzantium: a Critical Approach. Byzantinische Zeitschrift. 107/1, 175–220.
Trompf, G. 1979: The Idea of Historical Recurrence in Western Thought: From Antiquity to the Reformation. Berkeley.
van Ginkel, J.-J., Murre-Van den Berg, H.L., van Lint, T.M. (eds.), 2005: Redefi ning Christian Identity. Cultural Interaction in the Middle East since the Rise of Islam. Leuven–Paris– Dudley.
Wallace-Hadrill, D.S. 1960: Eusebius of Caesarea. London.
Whitby, M. 2006: Procopian Polemics: a Review of A. Kaldellis Procopius of Caesarea. Tyranny, History, and Philosophy at the End of Antiquity. The Classical Review 55(2), 648.
Zacharia, K. (ed.) 2008: Hellenisms: Culture, Identity and Ethnicity from Antiquity to Modernity. Aldershot.