Archive

A.G. Avdeev, А.V. Engovatova (Moscow) – Burial of Ivan Andreevich Buturlin in the Trinity-St. Sergius Monastery: to the Question of the Date of Execution and Posthumous Fate of the Disgraced Man

download PDF

Abstract

The article, written as part of the scientific project “Corpus Inscriptionum Rossicarum”, is a publication of a white-stone tombstone with an epitaph to Ivan Andreevich Buturlin. The monument was found in situ in 2007 during archaeological observations in the Trinity Lavra of St. Sergius, to the east of the southern narthex of the Assumption Cathedral. Under the slab, an undisturbed burial of an adult man was partially cleared, who had a broken fifth cervical vertebra, and all the teeth on the lower jaw and the front teeth on the upper jaw were knocked out approximately three months before his death. The epitaph made it possible to identify the discovered remains with the boyar Ivan Andreevich Buturlin, executed in the case of “treason” against Leonid, the Novgorod Archbishop, and to establish that he was executed on October 22, 1575, which was not known from other sources. Thus, the epitaph under study, in combination with archaeological, annalistic, hagiographic and memorial sources, provides important material for understanding the events of the internal political history of Russia in the last decade of Ivan the Terrible’s reign.

Keywords

Epigraphy of Moscow Russia, Corpus Inscriptionum Rossicarum, Trinity Lavra of St. Sergius, archaeological excavations, necropolis, Buturliny, Ivan the Terrible’s terror, funeral culture.

Aleksander G. Avdeev, Orthodox St.-Tikhon’s University, Moscow, Russia; Institute of Archeology of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Аsya V. Engovatova, Institute of Archaeology of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Andrey Kurbskiy – Andrey Kurbsky. Istoriya o delakh velikogo knyazya Moskovskogo [Andrey Kurbsky. History of the Aff airs of the Grand Duke of Moscow]. K.Y. Yerusalimskiy (ed.), A.A. Alekseev (transl.). Moscow, 2015.

Apukhtin, V.R. 1914: Pskovo-Pecherskiy Uspenskiy monastyr’ i ego vkladnaya kniga 1558 g.: kratkiy istoricheskiy ocherk [The Pskovo-Pechersky Dormition Monastery and Its Donation Book 1558: a Brief Historical Essay]. Moscow.

Avdeev, A.G. 2020: Regulirovanie zakhoroneniy na nekropolyakh Moskovskoy Rusi: pravila, normy, obychai, sueveriya [Regulation of Funerals in the Necropolis of Moscow Russia: Rules, Norms, Customs, Superstitions]. Vestnik Universiteta Dmitriya Pozharskogo 4 (20): Memorial’naya kul’tura Moskovskoy Rusi [Journal of Dmitry Pozharscky University 4 (20): The Memorial Culture of Moscow Russia], 7–77.

Avdeev, A.G., Stanyukovich, A.K. 2005: Novospasskiy pomyannik v spiskakh 18–19 vv. [Novospassky Pomyannik in Lists of the 18th–19th cc.]. In: Stanyukovich, A.K., Zvyagin, V.N., Chernosvitov, P.Yu., Elkina, I.I., Avdeev, A.G. Usypal’nitsa doma Romanovykh v Moskovskom Novospasskom monastyre [Tomb of the House of Romanov’s in the Moscow Novospassky Monastery]. Kostroma, 221–226.

Berkovich, V.A., Egorov, K.A. 2017: Moskovskoe belokamennoe nadgrobie. Katalog [Moscow Whitestone Tombstones. Catalogue]. Moscow.

Bulychev, A.A. 2005: Mezhdu svyatymi i demonami. Zametki o posmertnoy sud’be opal’nykh tsarya Ivana Groznogo [Between Saints and Demons. Notes on the Posthumous Fate of the Disgraced Tsar Ivan the Terrible]. Moscow.

CIR — Corpus Inscriptionum Rossicarum. https://www.cir.rssda.su/.

Engovatova, A.V., Vishnevskiy, V.I. 2010: Novye pamyatniki nekropolya Troitse-Sergieva monastyrya (materialy arkheologicheskikh nablyudeniy 2007 g.) [New Monuments of the Trinity-St. Sergius Monastery Necropolis (Materials of Archaeological Observations in 2007)]. In: Troitse-Sergieva lavra v istorii, kul’ture i dukhovnoy zhizni Rossii. Materialy VI mezhdunarodnoy konferentsii. 29–31 oktyabrya 2008 g. Tezisy dokladov VII mezhdunarodnoy konferentsii. 23–25 sentyabrya 2010 g. [Trinity-St. Sergius Lavra in the History, Culture and Spiritual Life of Russia. Materials of the 6th International Conference. October 29–31, 2008. Abstracts of the 7th International Conference. September 23–25, 2010] Sergiev Posad, 151–164.

Girshberg, V.B. 1960: Materialy dlya svoda nadpisey na kamennykh plitakh Moskvy i Podmoskov’ya XIV–XVII vv. Ch. 1: Nadpisi XIV–XVI vv. [Materials for the Corpus of Inscriptions on Stone Slabs of Moscow and the Moscow Region of the 14th – 17th cc. Pt. I: Inscriptions of the 14th–16th cc.] Numizmatika i epigrafika [Numismatics and Epigraphy] 1, 3–66.

Kormovaya kniga Moskovskogo stavropigial’nogo Novospasskogo monastyrya [Feeding Book of the Moscow Stavropigial Novospassky Monastery]. Moscow, 1903.

[Leonid (Kavelin), archimandrite] 1880: Spisok pogrebennykh v Troitskoy Sergievoy lavre ot osnovaniya onoy do 1880 goda [List of Those Buried in the Trinity st. Sergius Lavra from its Foundation to 1880]. Moscow.

Moskovsky letopisets [Moscow Chronicler]. In: Polnoe sobranie russkikh letopisey [Complete Collection of Russian Chronicles]. Vol. 34. Moscow, 221–237.

Muchenie sedmi otrok Efesskikh [The Martyrdom of the Seven Youngsters of Ephesus]. In: Velikie Minei Chet’i. Oktyabr’. Dni 19–31 [The Great Chet’yi Minei. October. Days 19-31]. Saint-Petersburg, 1773–1793, 1880.

Piskarevsky letopisets [Piskarevsky Chronicler]. In: Polnoe sobranie russkikh letopisey [Complete Collection of Russian Chronicles]. Vol. 34. Moscow, 1978, 31–220.

Pskovskaya 3-ya letopis’ [Pskov 3rd Chronicle]. In: Polnoe sobranie russkikh letopisey [Complete Collection of Russian Chronicles]. Vol. 5/2. Moscow, 2000, 251–290.

Rodoslovnye rospisi [Genealogical Records] – Shabaev, L.E. (ed.) 2021: Rodoslovnye rospisi, podannye v Palatu rodoslovnykh del v kontse XVII v.: provintsial’noe sluzhiloe dvoryanstvo (Velikiy Novgorod) [Genealogical Records Submitted to the Chamber of Genealogical Affairs at the End of the 17th c.: Provincial Servile Nobility (Veliky Novgorod)]. In: Rossiyskaya genealogiya. Nauchnyy al’manakh [The Russian Genealogy. The Scientific Almanac] 9. Moscow, 177–290.

Shokarev, S.Yu. 2019: Istochniki po istorii moskovskogo nekropolya XII – nachala XX v. [Sources on the History of the Moscow Necropolis of the 12th – early 20th Century]. Moscow– Saint Petersburg.

Shokarev, S.Yu. 2020: Stremilsya li Ivan Groznyy lishit’ svoikh zhertv khristianskogo pogrebeniya i spaseniya dushi? [Did Ivan the Terrible Seek to Deprive His Victims of Christian Burial and Salvation of the Spirit?]. In: I.G. Konovalova, E.V. Pchelov (eds.), Vspomogatel’nye istoricheskie distsipliny v sovremennom nauchnom znanii. Materialy 33 Mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoy konferentsii [Auxiliary Historical Disciplines in Modern Scientific Knowledge. Materials of the 33rd International Scientific Conference]. Moscow, 457–459.

Skrynnikov, R.G. 1992: Tsarstvo terrora [The Reign of Terror]. Saint Petersburg.

Synodik Troitse-Sergieva monastyrya, XVII v. [Synodic of the Trinity-St. Sergius Monastery, 17th c.]. Rossiyskaya gosudarstvennaya biblioteka. Otdel rukopisey. F. 304.I (Glavnoe sobranie rukopisey Troitse-Sergievoy lavry) [Russian State Library. Manuscripts Department. Collection 304.I (Main Collection of Manuscripts of the Trinity-St. Sergius Lavra). Nо. 818.

Veselovskiy, S. B. 1963: Issledovaniya po istorii oprichniny [Studies on the History of the Oprichnina]. Moscow.

Vkladnaya kniga [Book of Donations] – Klitina, E.N., Manushina, T.V., Nikolaeva, T.V (eds.). Vkladnaya kniga Troitse-Sergieva monastyrya, [Book of Donations of the Trinity-St. Sergius Monastery]. Moscow, 1987.

Yerusalimsky, K.Yu. 2009: Mezhdu kanonizirovannymi i demonizirovannymi: Kazni Ivana Groznogo v kul’turno-istoricheskoy interpretatsii (razmyshleniya nad knigoy A.A. Bulycheva). [Between Canonized and Demonized: The Executions by Ivan the Terrible in CulturalHistorical Interpretation (Refl ections on A.A. Bulychev’s Book)] In: Odissey. Chelovek v istorii 2009. 21. Puteshestvie kak istoriko-kul’turnyj fenomen [Odysseus. Man in History 2009. 21. Travelling as a Historical and Cultural Phenomenon]. Moscow, 361–390.

Details
Hits: 37