V.A. Kvashnin (Vologda) – On Paradox of Roman Sumptuary Laws

Русская версия

Abstract

Ancient authors developed a theory of moral decline, which linked the crisis of the Roman state with the process of decay of traditional norms and values (mos maiorum) under the infl uence of alien customs, of luxury and wealth. However, the fi rst Roman sumptuary laws had been taken earlier than gradual extension of luxury began. Lex Claudia, lex Metilia and lex Oppia of 218–215 BC were taken about 30 years before the triumphs of Scipio and Manlius. This gives the impression that in Roman society, barely faced the impact of luxury, had already existed both a theoretical understanding of the problem (philosophical doctrine of the decline of morals) and the practical mechanism in the form of sumptuary laws. The explanation of this paradox is related with the incorrect translation of the term «sumptuary laws» into Russian and other languages.

Перейти к содержимому PDF

Бартошек, М. 1989: Римское право: понятия, термины, определения. М.

Берве, Г. 1997: Тираны Греции. Пер. с нем. Ростов-на-Дону.

Дворецкий, И.Х. 1976: Латинско-русский словарь. Изд. 2-е. М.

Квашнин, В.А. 2006: Законы о роскоши в древнем Риме эпохи Пунических войн. Вологда.

Квашнин, В.А. 2009: Генезис сумптуарного законодательства в древнем Риме. Вологда.

Квашнин, В.А. 2010: «Столовые законы» в древнем Риме: К вопросу о соотношении тер- минов leges и sumptuariae leges cibariae. Древнее право 1 (25), 51–59.

Кнабе, Г.С. 1985: Историческое пространство и историческое время в культуре древнего Рима. В кн.: Е.С. Голубцова (ред.), Культура древнего Рима. Т. II. М., 108–166.

Кнабе, Г.С. 1994: Рим Тита Ливия – образ, миф и история. В кн.: Ливий Т. История Рима от основания города. T. III. М., 590–655.

Ляпустин, Б.С. 1991: Экономическое развитие древнего Рима в свете закона Оппия о ро- скоши. В кн.: С.К. Сизов (ред.), Из истории античного общества. Нижний Новгород, 50–62.

Утченко, С.Л. 1952: Идейно-политическая борьба в Риме накануне падения республики (Из истории политических идей I в. до н. э.). М.

Afzelius, A. 1942: Die rö mische Eroberung Italiens (340–264 v. Chr.). København.

Astin, A.E. 1978: Cato the Censor. Oxford.

Baltrusch, E. 1988: Regimen morum: Die Reglamentierung des Privatlebens der Senatoren und Ritter in der römischen Republik und frühen Kaiserreich. München.

Beloch, K. J. 1926: Römische Geschichte bis zum Beginn der punischen Kriege. Berlin–Leipzig.

Bottiglieri, A. 2002: La legislazione sul lusso nella Roma republicana. Napoli.

Cá ssola, F. 1962: I gruppi politici romani nel III secolo a. C. Trieste.

Chaniotis, A. 2005: War in the Hellenistic World: A Social and Cultural History. Oxford.

Cornell, T.J. 1989: The Conquest of Italy. In: F.W. Walbank, A.E. Astin, M.W. Frederiksen, R.M. Ogilvie, A. Drummond (eds.), The Cambridge Ancient History². VII/2. The Rise of Rome to 220 B.C. Cambridge, 351–419.

Dench, E. 1998: Austerity, Excess, Success and Failure in Hellenistic and Early Imperial Italy. In: M. Wyke (ed.), Parchments of Gender: Deciphering the Bodies of Antiqity. Oxford, 121–146.

Forsyte, G. 2006: A Critical History of Early Rome: From Prehistory to the First Punic War. Berkeley-Los Angelos–London.

Geffcken, J., Ziebart, E. (eds.) 1914: Lübkers Reallexikon des Klassischen Altertums. Leipzig– Berlin.

Glare, P.G.W. 1968: Oxford Latin Dictionary. Oxford.

Gruen, E.S. 1993: Culture and National Identity in Republican Rome. London.

Gruen, E.S. 1996: Studies in Greek Culture and Roman Policy. Berkeley–Los Angelos–London.

Hauri, A. 1976: Une «anné e de la femme» à Rome, 195 avant J.-C.? In: L’Italie pré romaine et la Rome ré publicaine. Melanges offerts à J. Heurgon. I. Roma, 427–436.

Huffman, C.A. 2005: Archytas of Tarentum: Pythagorean, Philosopher and Mathematician King. Cambridge.

Kübler, B. 1931: Sumptus. RE 16, 901–908.

Lange, L. 1876: Römische Altertümer. 3 Aufl . Berlin.

Lewis, Ch., Short, Ch. (eds.) 1958: A Latin Dictionary. Oxford.

Ligt de, L. 2002: Restraining the Rich, Protecting the Poor: Symbolic Aspects of Roman Legislation. In: W. Jongman, M. Kleijwegt (eds.), After the Past. Essays in Ancient History in Honour of H.W. Pleket. Leiden–Boston–Köln, 2–12.

Momigliano, A. 1975: Alien Wisdom: The Limits of Hellenisation. Cambridge.

Oakley, S. 1993: The Roman Сonquest of Italy. In: J. Rich, G. Shipley (eds.), War and Society in the Roman World. London–New York, 9–37.

Rawling, L. 2007: Army and Battle during the Conquest of Italy (350–264 B.C.). In: P. Erdcamp (ed.), A Companion to the Roman Army. Malden–Oxford–Carlton, 45–62.

Sauerwein, I. 1970: Die leges sumptuariae als romische Maßnahme gegen den Sittenverfall. Hamburg.

Wieacker, F. 1961: Vom römischen Recht. 2 Aufl . Stuttgart.

Ziegler, K., Sontheimer, W. (eds.) 1964: Der Kleine Pauly Lexikon der Antike. Stuttgart.