U.V. Kornilov (Novosibirsk) – Panhellenism and the Eastern Campaign of Alexander the Great: the Historiographic Review
Abstract
The article deals with Alexander’s the Great panhellenic ideology, during his Eastern campaign. The author pays attention to the historiographical situation of the problem taking into account domestic and foreign achievements to make conclusion that the problem of Alexander’s Panhellenism hasn’t been suffi ciently researched. It should be pointed out that both in Soviet historiography, and in some cases in the foreign historiography of panhellenism Alexander’s the Great ideology is considered very superfi cially and is a part of the review of the problem of pan-hellenism in general. At the same time, little research has been devoted to Alexander’s panhellism, especially in Russia. In addition, the author explores Alexander’s panhellenism in the East. Using the comprehensive analysis of the ancient narrative tradition, the author regards the ideology of panhellenism since Persian invasion to 330 BC, indicating the burning of Persepolis as a key event. After the pointed occasion, the panhellenic demonstration in the narrative sources became rare. Considering this event to be a key one in the aspect of changing the ideologies of Alexander the Great, the author nevertheless points to cases of panhellenistic propaganda after changing ideologies. After replacing, panhellenistic ideology with orientalism, the demonstration of panhellenistic slogans was a necessity. The need to justify themselves to their Macedonian-Greek environment, to demonstrate their achievements in the conquest of the wealth of the East was the reason for the use of “outdated slogans” of panhellenism. Later, when orientalism was used as a new course, the Greek-Macedonian opposition of Alexander began to use panhellenistic ideology against the new «King of Asia». The purpose of the attempt was to stop the political tendency of offi cial political course. The conclusion is that panellinism has evolved naturally: from the official ideology, panellinism turns into the opposition ideology of some representatives of the Greek-Macedonian elite.
Алленова, И.В. 2002: Панэллинизм Исократа. ТГУ 2 (26), 63–66.
Гафуров, Б.Г., Цибукидис, Д.И. 1980: Александр Македонский и Восток. М.
Исаева, В.И. 1990: Идеологическая подготовка эллинизма. В кн.: Г.А. Кошеленко, Э.Д. Фролов, В.И. Исаева и др. (ред.), Эллинизм: экономика, политика, культура. М., 59–88.
Корнилов, Ю.В. 2015: Идеология Александра Великого: от панэллинизма к ориентализму. Патриотизм и коллаборационизм в мировой истории. Казань, 37–42.
Корнилов, Ю.В. 2017: Ориентализм в идеологии и политике Александра Великого. Казань.
Кошеленко, Г.А., Фролова Э.Д., Исаева, В.И. (ред.): 1990 Эллинизм: экономика, политика, культура. М.
Маринович, Л.П. 1993: Греки и Александр Македонский (К проблеме кризиса полиса). М.
Меланченко, И.В. 2002: Панэллинистические идеи в политическом мировоззрении Исократа. Антиковедение и Медиевистика 4, 3–15.
Ранович, А.Б. 1950: Эллинизм и его историческая роль. М.–Л.
Рунг, Э.В. 2009. Греко-персидские отношения: политика, идеология, пропаганда. Казань.
Фролов, Э.В. 1990: Исторические предпосылки эллинизма. В кн.: Г.А. Кошеленко, Э.Д. Фролов, В.И. Исаева и др. (ред.), Эллинизм: экономика, политика, культура. М., 59–88.
Фролов, Э.Д. 1983: Панэллинизм в политике IV в. до н.э. В кн.: Е.С. Голубцова (ред.), Античная Греция: Проблемы развития полиса. Т. 2. М., 157–207.
Цибукидис, Д.И. 1981: Древняя Греция и Восток. Эллинистическая проблематика греческой историографии (1850–1971). М.
Шофман, А.С. 1976: Восточная политика Александра Македонского. Казань.
Antela-Bernárdez, B. 2007: Hegemony and Panhellenism: Political Concepts in the Age of Philip and Alexander. Dialogues d’histoire ancienne 2 (33/2), 69–89.
Flower, M. 2000: Alexander the Great and Panhellenism. In: A.B. Bosworth, E.J. Baynham (ed.), Alexander the Great in fact and fi ction. Oxford, 96–135.
Isaac, B. 2004: The invention of Racism in Classical Antiquity. Princeton.
Mitchell, L. 2007. Panhellenism and the Barbarian in Archaic and Classical Greece. Cambridge.
Seager, R. 1981: The Freedom of the Greeks of Asia: From Alexander to Antiochus. Classical Quarterly 31.1, 106–112.