T.Yu. Shashlova (Saratov) – Source Study Remarks on the One Ctesias of Cnidus’ Message
Abstract
The article is devoted to the analysis of one known fragment of Ctesias of Cnidus, Greek author of the second half of the 5th – the beginnings of the 4th century BC. In his work “Persica”, he talks about a sea raid of the satrap of Cappadocia Ariaramnes to the lands of European Scythia, during which a number of captives including the brother of the Scythian king Marsaget was taken. According to Ctesias, the Ariaramnes’ action preceded a campaign of Darius I against the Scythians in 512 BC. Ctesias’ information about Ariaramnes’ expedition is unique; any other ancient author does not mention this event. Herodotus who describes in detail the attempt of the Persians to conquer Scythia also says nothing about the Ariaramnes’ action. At the same time, the considered passage of Ctesias has a number of parallels with the content of line 20–30 of column V of the Behistun inscription, where it is spoken about Darius’ conquest of the Central Asian Saka-Massagetae. Scientists have already noted this fact, and it has been suggested that in both cases this is about the same event. However, there are not only similarities but also differences in the text of Ctesias and the Behistun inscription. This fact, as well as the general reputation of Ctesias as an unreliable author, constantly attempting to “correct” Herodotus, to add to his story unknown to the Greeks events, allows us to assume that his report about the campaign of Ariaramnes is rather a distorted transmission of the text of the Behistun inscription, which he put in a different historical context, having changed at the same time some details.
Агбунов, М.В. 1987: Античная лоция Черного моря. М.
Гайдукевич, В.Ф. 1969: О путях прохождения древнегреческих кораблей в Понте Эвксинском. КСИА 116, 11–19.
Дандамаев, М.А. 1963: Иран при первых Ахеменидах. М.
Дандамаев, М.А. 1985: Политическая история Ахеменидской державы. М.
Дандамаев, М.А. 2013: Ахеменидская империя. Социально-административное устройство и культурные достижения. СПб.
Дьяконов, И.М. 1956: История Мидии. М.–Л.
Кошеленко, Г.А. 1999: Об одном свидетельстве Диодора о ранней истории Боспорского царства. В сб.: А.В. Подосинов (ред.), Древнейшие государства Восточной Европы. 1996–1997. М., 130–141.
Кузищин, И.В. (ред.) 2002: История древнего Востока. Тексты и документы. М.
Максимова, М.И. 1954: Краткий путь через Черное море и время его освоения греческими мореходами. МИА 33, 45–57.
Максимова, М.И. 1956: Античные города Юго-Восточного Причерноморья. М.–Л.
Пьянков, И.В. 1975: Ктесий как историк. В сб.: Античная древность и средние века 11. Свердловск, 52–57.
Сапрыкин, С.Ю. 1986: Гераклея Понтийская и Херсонес Таврический. М.
Струве, В.В. 1946: Дарий I и скифы Причерноморья. ВДИ 2, 15–28.
Суриков, И.Е. 1999: Историко-географические проблемы Понтийской экспедиции Перикла. ВДИ 2, 98–113. Черненко, Е.В. 1984: Скифо-персидская война. Киев.
Яйленко, В.П. 2010: Военная акция Дария I на Киммерийском Боспоре. В кн.: Тысячелетний Боспорский рейх. История и эпиграфика Боспора VI в. до н.э. – V в. н.э. М., 7–11.
Briant, P. 2002: From Cyrus to Alexander. A History of the Persian Empire. Winona Lake.
Descat, R. 1990: Remarques sur les rapports entre les Perses et la mer Noire à lʹépoque achéménide. In: Congrès international sur la mer Noire1–3 juin 1988 à Samsun. Samsun, 539–548.
Nieling, J. 2010: Persian Imperial Policy Behind the Rise and Fall of the Cimmerian Bosporus in the Last Quarter of the Sixth to the Beginning of the Fifth Century BC. In: J. Nieling, E. Rehm (ed.), Achaemenid Impact in the Black Sea. Communication of Powers. Aarhus, 123–136.
Stronk, J.P. 2010: Ctesias’ Persian History. Part 1. Introduction, Text and Translation. Düsseldorf.
Summerer, L. 2003: Achämenidische Silberfunde aus der Umgebung von Sinope. ACSS 9, 1–2, 17–42.