S.A. Davydov (St. Petersburg) – Despotism in the Management Practices of Ancient Egypt’s Economy: Myths and Reality

Русская версия

Abstract

The article considers the problem of despotism in the management practice of the Ancient Egyptian economic system. The author puts forward the suggestion that the Ancient Egyptian disciplinary sanctions in general were not excessively cruel, the activities of offi cials was limited by cultural and institutional systems and was under social control. There is no doubt that the leaders of Egyptcould not do without negative sanctions in the management of economic complex. Punishment took a great part in the management of motivation and formation of workers’ conformism. But the Egyptian rulers constantly took care of the development of rules limiting spontaneity of condemnation and determined a long way to co-ordinatethe disciplinary measures at different levels of the bureaucratic pyramid. In addition, legislators of the Nile state rarely established the need for the death penalty - a measure, widespread in other countries of the ancient world. On the basis of the available data it can be judged that this frightening instrument was rarely aimed at preventing even the most serious economic crimes, such as “improper” use of God’shouse property. The Ancient Egyptian system of economic management had no clear evidence of other trait, closely associated with the concept of despotism- arbitrariness perpetrated by the rulers and dignitaries. Today there is no doubt that the authorities of ancient Egypt had to carry out their activities in framework of social and cultural constraints.

Перейти к содержимому PDF

Брокгауз, Ю.Ф., Ефрон, И.А. 1907: Малый энциклопедический словарь. Т. 1. Вып. 2. СПб.

Демидчик, А.Е. 2005: Безымянная пирамида. Государственная доктрина древнеегипетской Гераклеопольской монархии. СПб.

Демидчик, А.Е. 2006: Смертная казнь в уголовном праве Египта периода Старого Царства. Вестник НГУ. Серия: Право. Т. 2. Вып. 2., 10–14.

Коростовцев, М.А. 1980: Хрестоматия по истории древнего востока. Ч. I. М.

Маркс, К. 1958: Введение (Из экономических рукописей 1857-1858 годов). М.

Маркс К., Энгельс, Ф. 1956: Сочинения. Т. 12. М.

Нежинский, Ю.В. 2009: Смертная казнь в эллинистическом Египте. Вестник СПбГУ. Сер. 2. Вып. 1, 157–160.

Перепелкин, Ю.Я. 1988: Хозяйство старо-египетских вельмож. М.

Савельева, Т.Н. 1962: Аграрный строй Египта в период Древнего царства. М.

Струве, В.В. 1950: Хрестоматия по истории древнего мира. Т. 1. М.

Чегодаев, М.А. 1994: Древнеегипетская Книга Мертвых – фрагменты перевода и комментарии. Вопросы истории 9, 141–151.

Erichsen, W. 1933: Papyrus Harris. Hieroglyphische Transcription. Bibliotheca Aegyptica. Vol. V. Bruxelles.

Gardiner, А.Н. 1932: Late-Egyptian Stories. Bruxelies.

Griffi th, F.Ll. 1927: The Abidos Decree of Seti at Nauri. Journal of Egyptian Archeology. Vol. 13; 3/4 (Nov.), 199.

Helck, W. 1955: Urkunden der 18 Dynastie. Berlin, 1299–1309.

Helck, W. 1957: Urkunden der 18 Dynastie. Berlin, 1659–1661.

Maspero, Q. 1872: Du genre epistolaire chez les egyptiens de l’epoque pharaonique. Paris.

Muller, W.М. 1902: Der Bundnisvertrag-Ramses II und des Chetiterkorigs. Mitteilungen der Vorderasiatischen Gesellschaft. Bd. V, 193–203.

Sethe, K. 1932: Urkunden des Alten Reichs. Leipzig.

Sethe, К. 1905–1909: Urkunden der 18 Dynastie. Leipzig.

Sethe, К. 1933: Urkunden des mittleren Reiches. Urkunden des agyptischen Altertums. Leipzig.

Taubenschlag, R. 1944: Law of Greco-Roman Egypt in the Light of Papyri. New York.

Vogelsang, F. 1913: Kommentar zu den Klagen des Bauern. Leipzig.

Weill, R. 1912: Les Decrets royaux de l’ancien empire egyptien. Paris.

Wittfogel, K. 1957: Oriental despotism: a comparative study of total power. New Haven.