download PDF

Abstract

The article deals with the problem of concepts’ changing of early Greek tyranny in the Russian historiography. On the basis of the analysis of the 19th and 20th centuries works, the author comes to the following conclusions. First conception of early Greek tyranny was formed in the works of 19th century scientists and kept its scientifi c relevance till the middle of the 20th century. Within the framework of this concept the tyranny was characterized as a stage of formation of Greek democracy. As a result of struggle for political power between nobility and demos a tyrant, supported by masses, becomes head of polis. This tyrant carries out a series of measures aimed at the development of crafts, trade and support of the small peasantry. The fall of the tyranny was assessed in different ways. In pre-revolutionary historiography the overthrow of tyrants was explained by their personal qualities. In Soviet studies, however, became fi rmly established the viewpoint that the demos did not need tyrants after the aristocracy had been weakened. In the 1960s, an alternative conception began to take shape. In this concept, tyranny is seen as a result of a struggle between aristocratic groups. The policy of the tyrant is interpreted as a set of measures aimed at legitimizing personal power. Tyranny does not refl ect the interests of the demos, but has to reckon with them. This transition is connected with changes in world and domestic historiography, since in the 1960s-1970s a new conception of the socio-economic and political essence of archaic Greece was gradually established. Nevertheless, in modern Russian historiography we can fi nd supporters of both the updated and improved concept of democratic tyranny and those researchers who see tyrants as only a particular manifestation of aristocratic conflicts of archaic times.

Keywords

Historiography, Archaic Greece, polis, Early Greek tyranny, Athens, Peisistratus.

Dmitriy V. Zaytsev

Russian State University for the Humanities, Moscow, Russia

Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration, Moscow, Russia

E-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Bauer, V.V. 1863: Epokha drevney tiranii v Gretsii [The Age of Ancient Tyranny in Greece]. Saint Petersburg.

Buzeskul, V.P. 1909: Istoriya Afi nskoy demokratii [History of Athenian Democracy]. Saint Petersburg.

Zhestokanov, S.M. 2010: Rannyaya tiraniya i stanovlenie demokratii v drevney Gretsii [Early Tyranny and the Formation of Democracy in Ancient Greece]. In E.D. Frolov (ed.), Problemy antichnoy demokratii [Problems of ancient democracy]. Saint Petersburg, 25–50.

Zel’in, K.K. 1962: Olimpioniki i tirany [Olympic Champions and Tyrants]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 4, 21–29.

Zel’in, K.K. 1964: Bor’ba politicheskikh gruppirovok v Attike v VI v. do n.e. [The Struggle of Political Factions in Attica in the 6th century BC]. Moscow.

Kobylina, M.M. Milet [Miletus]. Moscow.

Kolobova, K.M., Gluskina L.M. 1958: Ocherki istorii Drevney Gretsii [Essays on the History of Ancient Greece]. Leningrad.

Krikh, S.B. 2013: Obraz drevnosti v sovetskoy istoriografi i [The Image of Antiquity in Soviet Historiography]. Moscow.

Lapteva, M.Yu. 2009: U istokov drevnegrecheskoy tsivilizatsii: Ioniya v XI–VI vv. do n.e. [At sources of an Ancient Greek civilization: Ionia in 11th–6th centuries BC]. Saint Petersburg.

Latyshev, V.V. 1997: Ocherk grecheskikh drevnostey. Chast’ 1. Gosudarstvennye i voennye drevnosti [An Essay on Greek Antiquities. Part 1. State and Military Antiquities]. Saint Petersburg.

Lur’e, S.Ya. 1993: Istoriya Gretsii [The History of Greece]. Saint Petersburg.

Makarov, I.A. 1995: Tiraniya I Del’fy v ramkakh politicheskoy istorii Gretsii vtoroy poloviny VII–VI vv. do n.e. [Tyranny and Delphi within the Framework of the Political History of Greece of the Second Half of the 7th–6th c. B.C.] Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 4, 117–131.

Makarov, I.A. 1997: Ideogicheskie aspekty rannegrecheskoy tiranii [The Ideological Aspects of Early Greek Tyranny]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 2, 25–42.

Novikova, T.F. 1965: Rannegrecheskaya tiraniya na Korinfskom peresheyke [Early Greek Tyranny on the Isthmus of Corinth]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 4, 112–126.

Pilenkova, T.F. 1975: Rannegrecheskaya tiraniya na Samose [Early Greek tyranny in Samos]. In.: Ya.V. Zaytsev (ed.), Problemy sotsialno-politicheskoy istorii antichnosti i srednevekov’ya [Problems of the Social and Political History of Antiquity and the Middle Ages]. Vol. 1. Ufa, 3–25.

Sergeev, V.S. 1963: Istoriya Drevney Gretsii [The History of Ancient Greece]. Moscow.

Solov’yeva, S.S. 1964: Rannegrecheskaya tiraniya [Early Greek tyranny]. Moscow.

Strogetskiy, V.M. 2015: Fukidid o vozniknovenii tiranii v Drevney Gretsii, ob osobennostyakh afinskoy tiranii Pisistratidov i zagovore Garmodiya i Aristogitona [Thucydides about Rising of Tyranny in Ancient Greece, Character of the Peisistratid Tyranny at Athens and the Plot of Harmodius and Aristogeiton]. In E.D. Frolov (ed.), Mnemon: Issledovaniya i publikatsii po istorii antichnogo mira [Mnemon: Investigation and Publication on the History of Ancient World]. Vol. 15. Saint Petersburg, 34–48.

Surikov, I.E. 2005: Antichnaya Gretsiya. Politiki v kontekste epokhi. Arkhaika i rannyaya klassika [Ancient Greece. Polticians in the Context of the Epoch. Archaic and Early Classical Periods]. Moscow.

Tumans, Kh. 2002: Rozhdenie Afiny: Afinskiy put’ k demokratii ot Gomera do Perikla (VIII – V vv. do n.e.) [The birth of Athens: The Athenian Way to democracy: from Homer to Pericles (8th–5th centuries BC)]. Saint Petersburg.

Tyumenev, A.N. 1935: Istoriya antichnykh rabovladel’cheskikh obshhestv [The History of ancient slave societies]. Moscow.

Frolov, E.D. 2004а: Paradoksy istorii – paradoksy antichnosti [Paradoxes of History - Paradoxes of Antiquity]. Saint Petersburg.

Frolov, E.D. 2004b: Rozhdenie grecheskogo polisa [The birth of the Greek polis]. Saint Petersburg. Khvostov, M.M. 2007: Istoriya Gretsii [The History of Greece]. Moscow.

Yaylenko, V.P. 1983: Arkhaicheskaya Gretsiya [Archaic Greece]. In E.S. Golubtsova (ed.), Antichnaya Gretsiya: problemy razvitiya polisa. T. 1. Stanovlenie i razvitie polisa [Ancient Greece: Problems of the Development of the Polis. Vol. 1. Formation and Development of the Polis]. Moscow, 128–193.